Satisfactory HDV to SD Conversion

[Bill Watson]

Anybody come up with a satisfactory workflow from HDV (1080, 50i) to SD/DVD in Vegas 7/DVD Architect yet?

I've tried all combinations of options to get a clean SD in 7d but am still plagued with artifacts when I burn or prepare file to DVD.

I'm doing it on a mate's system (dual core, Raid array, very fast and efficient) as I'm still undecided as to what software will do the job best.

I've followed all the threads (well, most of them anyway) and tried changing fields, progressive, bit rates, blah blah.

I don't see the de-interlacing filter as an option as it just seems to blur the pix.

I know some people seem deliriously happy with their SD results from HD which is all the more frustrating.

[Laurence Kingston]

Have you tried the free VASST script here?:

http://www.vasst2.com/product.aspx?i...4-951b88a127b1

It seems to work quite well and is pretty much idiot-proof.

The only thing you need to watch for if you use this script is that you select "best" for rendering quality since "best" uses a better resize algorythm.

[Bill Watson]

Thanks for that.

Downloaded and tried it. No good.

Anybody got any workflows they'd care to share?

By the way, I'm using a Canon XH-A1.

Be nice if I could get some SD footage at least as good as my little Panasonic GS400.

[Laurence Kingston]

Also, in Vegas, it's really important to select a deinterlace method when you resize interlaced video. This includes downrezzing HD to SD. It's not that you actually deinterlace. It's that if a deinterlace method is not selected, it will resize like the footage is progressive. This will give you jagged vertical lines on any motion. Select a deinterlace method and the footage will resize the two interlace fields separately.

[Douglas Spotted Eagle]

I'm a bit baffled that you're having a problem with HDV to SD.
Shoot HDV.
Capture HDV
Edit HDV on an HDV timeline. Be sure you're using the *HDV* and not *HD* templates for your framerates.
After you're finished, and you are ready for output;
Choose the DVD Architect PAL Widescreen template.
Be sure the "Stretch to fill" checkbox is ticked.
That should be it.

While I've only done this a bit with the 25p/50i templates, I follow this daily with 24p, 30p or 60i originated HDV.
If you do choose to deinterlace, you can get a reasonably good deinterlace by choosing the Custom Tab and using "Interpolate" vs "blend."

[Alastair Brown]

I'm a PAL user and also have an XH-A1. Having no problems at all making great looking DVD's using Vegas and DVDA.

As per DSE's recommendations above, I shoot in HDV, capture/edit in HDV then render to DVD Architect PAl Widescreen Template.

If you want to e-mail me, I'd be happy to do some screen grabs of my project settings although to be honest I am pretty sure they are just the default ones.

[Bill Watson]

Thanks guys.

I'll go back to basics, delete all the test files I've accumulated and try again.

.... I'll be back.......