24p dvd at DVinfo.net

Bill LiPera · September 29th, 2012, 09:27 PM

How does one make a 24P dvd in dvd architect. I've made one from the vegas timeline (a 24p option exists) but the quality is only fair. I used an old program called DVD workshop and TMPGEnc (after rendering the timeline to an uncompressed avi) and the quality is much better. This program is 7 years old. What gives?

John Estcourt · September 29th, 2012, 11:14 PM

Bill, sorry I can't help you with regards to DVD architect, however the reason the qualirty is better rendering out to an Avi frst is that Tmpgenc mastering works is a far superior mpeg encoder than sony vegas.
That would be my prefered route every time. The authoring software shouldnt make any difference to the equality as long as it isnt re encoding.
The files from tmpgenc should however inport into architect without problem if you are producing elementary streams of audio and video.
Cheers john

Peter Manojlovic · September 30th, 2012, 08:21 AM

Hey Bill....

Another factor, is that some encoders take your lovely 24fps video, and hard telecine it to 29.97.
Basically rehandling your video, rather that encoding it native, and simply adding the telecine flags to the video stream...
If you're happy with the quality of your 24fps video, then search for an encoder that will respect the frame rate.

Ron Evans · September 30th, 2012, 12:30 PM

Remember to watch 24P you will need a playback system that will do this. Most playback systems will need to apply 2:3 pulldown to sync with the refresh rate of the display. I think currently a Bluray disc played over HDMI to a display having a refresh rate a multiple of 24 is the only way of avoiding the 2:3 cadence. Some plasmas and PC monitors can have a 72Hz rate and some LCD TV's of 120 and 240Hz will have the necessary display characteristics. They emulate a film projector with mutliple blade shutters to play at 24fps with a shutter flicker rate at the display refresh rate. You will always need 2:3 cadence to watch on a 60Hz monitor or TV.

Ron Evans

Chris Barcellos · September 30th, 2012, 12:46 PM

One thing I have done with HD material that I was rendering to a standard DVD is render it out a finished Cineform AVI to an 1280 x 720 MPG 4 file first (Mainconcept). Then I render to Sony DVD architect file that adds pulldown. The two step render process seems to work out better. So render process is:

Project rendered to Cineform HD file, for master

Master rendered to 1280 x 720 mpg4, still in 24p. (actually 23.97)

Mpg 4 intermediate rendered to DVD Architect DVD 24p with pull down added

Marcus Martell · September 30th, 2012, 02:49 PM

Guys sorry 4 the question but if you e editing 24p footage, what 'a the best output to render to have a fluid preview on internet or DVD?
Thx

September 29th, 2012, 09:27 PM	#1
Bill LiPera Regular Crew Join Date: Sep 2012 Location: St. James New York Posts: 27	24p dvd How does one make a 24P dvd in dvd architect. I've made one from the vegas timeline (a 24p option exists) but the quality is only fair. I used an old program called DVD workshop and TMPGEnc (after rendering the timeline to an uncompressed avi) and the quality is much better. This program is 7 years old. What gives?

September 29th, 2012, 11:14 PM	#2
John Estcourt Major Player Join Date: Oct 2007 Location: Scotland, Ayr www.amour weddingvideos.co.uk Posts: 305	Re: 24p dvd Bill, sorry I can't help you with regards to DVD architect, however the reason the qualirty is better rendering out to an Avi frst is that Tmpgenc mastering works is a far superior mpeg encoder than sony vegas. That would be my prefered route every time. The authoring software shouldnt make any difference to the equality as long as it isnt re encoding. The files from tmpgenc should however inport into architect without problem if you are producing elementary streams of audio and video. Cheers john __________________ john estcourt www.amourweddingvideos.co.uk

September 30th, 2012, 08:21 AM	#3
Peter Manojlovic Major Player Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Hamilton Ontario Posts: 769	Re: 24p dvd Hey Bill.... Another factor, is that some encoders take your lovely 24fps video, and hard telecine it to 29.97. Basically rehandling your video, rather that encoding it native, and simply adding the telecine flags to the video stream... If you're happy with the quality of your 24fps video, then search for an encoder that will respect the frame rate.

September 30th, 2012, 12:30 PM	#4
Ron Evans Inner Circle Join Date: Mar 2003 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada Posts: 4,222	Re: 24p dvd Remember to watch 24P you will need a playback system that will do this. Most playback systems will need to apply 2:3 pulldown to sync with the refresh rate of the display. I think currently a Bluray disc played over HDMI to a display having a refresh rate a multiple of 24 is the only way of avoiding the 2:3 cadence. Some plasmas and PC monitors can have a 72Hz rate and some LCD TV's of 120 and 240Hz will have the necessary display characteristics. They emulate a film projector with mutliple blade shutters to play at 24fps with a shutter flicker rate at the display refresh rate. You will always need 2:3 cadence to watch on a 60Hz monitor or TV. Ron Evans

September 30th, 2012, 12:46 PM	#5
Chris Barcellos Inner Circle Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: Elk Grove CA Posts: 6,838	Re: 24p dvd One thing I have done with HD material that I was rendering to a standard DVD is render it out a finished Cineform AVI to an 1280 x 720 MPG 4 file first (Mainconcept). Then I render to Sony DVD architect file that adds pulldown. The two step render process seems to work out better. So render process is: Project rendered to Cineform HD file, for master Master rendered to 1280 x 720 mpg4, still in 24p. (actually 23.97) Mpg 4 intermediate rendered to DVD Architect DVD 24p with pull down added __________________ Chris J. Barcellos

September 30th, 2012, 02:49 PM	#6
Marcus Martell Trustee Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: spain Posts: 1,202	Re: 24p dvd Guys sorry 4 the question but if you e editing 24p footage, what 'a the best output to render to have a fluid preview on internet or DVD? Thx