Judging Tips for UWOL #6...and a chance to Win a free UWOL t-shirt! at DVinfo.net

Meryem Ersoz · November 21st, 2007, 03:16 PM

I'm posting this a little prematurely, because we are coming up on a major US holiday, and I know that holiday scheduling can get tricky.

Remember, we are judging this internally this round. Every player who posts a UWOL #6 entry is qualified to judge. Send me your top 3 picks to uwol@comcast.net. Assign 3 points to your 1st choice, 2 points to your 2nd, and 1 point to your third. Most total points wins the round. Try to write up your evaluation as we expect our outside judges to write an evaluation, and I will publish anonymously some of the best comments on the winning entries. Reminder: You can't vote for your own entry.

Also, we are having a free t-shirt giveaway to the person who assigns the most thoughtful commentary on any of the top three films. And we are going to open this aspect of the judging to anyone, anyone at all, finisher, shark-tanker, interested by-stander, kibbitzer, anyone who wants to participate in the UWOL Challenge as a film critic by generating excellent commentary for our top contenders is invited to vie for the free UWOL shirt. Just send me an e-mail at uwol@comcast.net with the words "Judging UWOL" in the subject line (so that I don't filter it).

All votes and comments must be received by Sunday November 25 to be considered valid.

The t-shirt design is shaping up and looking good. Our design guru, Mat, is getting close with his design....

PARAMETERS FOR JUDGING:

50% of your judging should be weighed towards production values (shooting,
editing, lighting, audio, composition, cinematography, motion, etc.)
50% of your judging should focus on the use of the theme (did the entry hit the
mark, its creativity, the ability to work the theme, approach, etc.)

Remember that this is a nature and outdoors contest, and it is also important
that the winning entry should also reflect the overall spirit of the event...if you have any questions, see
our mission statement and our website at to get a feel for that spirit:

www.uwolchallenge.com

Oh, and one final note: CONGRATULATIONS TO THIS YEAR'S UWOL RING OF FAME!
The following players earned their free t-shirts by finishing all six UWOL Challenges this year:

Geir Inge
Gordon Hoffman
Brian Mckay
Bruce Foreman
Chris Barcellos
Per Johan
Ruth Happel
Dale Guthormsen

You folks did amazing, amazing work. Congratulations and thank you for your awesome contribution to building the most excellent community of nature and outdoors shooters on the planet.

Meryem Ersoz · November 23rd, 2007, 09:42 AM

one overlooked instruction--my entries are always non-competitive, so "Insomnia" is not eligible for voting. I guess I have been doing this for long enough, that I take it for granted that everyone already knows this....

I'm thrilled that someone gave it a 2nd place finish yesterday, however, I had to reject this kindness and request a replacement.

ooooo, that was hard! now I know how you competitors feel!

Bryce Comer · November 25th, 2007, 04:28 AM

Well guys,
It's Sunday night here in Oz, so i've just submited my top 3. Boy was that an effort!!! I wish i was judging snow skiing, that would have been a lot easier for me as i spent 11 ski seasons as an instructor in the snow fields in Australia, & Austria, so looking at someones skiing and being able to give them consice feedback on how they could improve it would have been a whole lot easier. Having said that, i definately learnt a heck of a lot about my own skiing in the process of teaching others to ski.
Athough the process of judging was a challenge in itself, i think the excercise will make us all think more about the way we as the "film makers" go about making our films.
At the rate Meryem is thowing up all these challenges to the group, i'm sure everyones films will be going from strength to strength.

Good luck to all,

Bryce.

Trond Saetre · November 25th, 2007, 09:31 AM

Being a judge is NOT an easy job!!!

I'm sitting here watching all the video's over and over again, trying to come up with the 3 best. The only problem is, all of the videos have something special. Makes me look at the videos in a totally different way than I used to. The judging is fun, but even harder than to make the video itself.

GOOD LUCK with the judging everyone!

November 21st, 2007, 03:16 PM	#1
Meryem Ersoz Wrangler Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Boulder, CO Posts: 3,015	Judging Tips for UWOL #6...and a chance to Win a free UWOL t-shirt! I'm posting this a little prematurely, because we are coming up on a major US holiday, and I know that holiday scheduling can get tricky. Remember, we are judging this internally this round. Every player who posts a UWOL #6 entry is qualified to judge. Send me your top 3 picks to uwol@comcast.net. Assign 3 points to your 1st choice, 2 points to your 2nd, and 1 point to your third. Most total points wins the round. Try to write up your evaluation as we expect our outside judges to write an evaluation, and I will publish anonymously some of the best comments on the winning entries. Reminder: You can't vote for your own entry. Also, we are having a free t-shirt giveaway to the person who assigns the most thoughtful commentary on any of the top three films. And we are going to open this aspect of the judging to anyone, anyone at all, finisher, shark-tanker, interested by-stander, kibbitzer, anyone who wants to participate in the UWOL Challenge as a film critic by generating excellent commentary for our top contenders is invited to vie for the free UWOL shirt. Just send me an e-mail at uwol@comcast.net with the words "Judging UWOL" in the subject line (so that I don't filter it). All votes and comments must be received by Sunday November 25 to be considered valid. The t-shirt design is shaping up and looking good. Our design guru, Mat, is getting close with his design.... PARAMETERS FOR JUDGING: 50% of your judging should be weighed towards production values (shooting, editing, lighting, audio, composition, cinematography, motion, etc.) 50% of your judging should focus on the use of the theme (did the entry hit the mark, its creativity, the ability to work the theme, approach, etc.) Remember that this is a nature and outdoors contest, and it is also important that the winning entry should also reflect the overall spirit of the event...if you have any questions, see our mission statement and our website at to get a feel for that spirit: www.uwolchallenge.com Oh, and one final note: CONGRATULATIONS TO THIS YEAR'S UWOL RING OF FAME! The following players earned their free t-shirts by finishing all six UWOL Challenges this year: Geir Inge Gordon Hoffman Brian Mckay Bruce Foreman Chris Barcellos Per Johan Ruth Happel Dale Guthormsen You folks did amazing, amazing work. Congratulations and thank you for your awesome contribution to building the most excellent community of nature and outdoors shooters on the planet.

November 23rd, 2007, 09:42 AM	#2
Meryem Ersoz Wrangler Join Date: Jan 2005 Location: Boulder, CO Posts: 3,015	one overlooked instruction--my entries are always non-competitive, so "Insomnia" is not eligible for voting. I guess I have been doing this for long enough, that I take it for granted that everyone already knows this.... I'm thrilled that someone gave it a 2nd place finish yesterday, however, I had to reject this kindness and request a replacement. ooooo, that was hard! now I know how you competitors feel!

November 25th, 2007, 04:28 AM	#3
Bryce Comer Trustee Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Rossland, British Columbia Posts: 1,024	Well guys, It's Sunday night here in Oz, so i've just submited my top 3. Boy was that an effort!!! I wish i was judging snow skiing, that would have been a lot easier for me as i spent 11 ski seasons as an instructor in the snow fields in Australia, & Austria, so looking at someones skiing and being able to give them consice feedback on how they could improve it would have been a whole lot easier. Having said that, i definately learnt a heck of a lot about my own skiing in the process of teaching others to ski. Athough the process of judging was a challenge in itself, i think the excercise will make us all think more about the way we as the "film makers" go about making our films. At the rate Meryem is thowing up all these challenges to the group, i'm sure everyones films will be going from strength to strength. Good luck to all, Bryce.

November 25th, 2007, 09:31 AM	#4
Trond Saetre Inner Circle Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: Bergen, Norway Posts: 3,375	Being a judge is NOT an easy job!!! I'm sitting here watching all the video's over and over again, trying to come up with the 3 best. The only problem is, all of the videos have something special. Makes me look at the videos in a totally different way than I used to. The judging is fun, but even harder than to make the video itself. GOOD LUCK with the judging everyone!