SD Downconvertion from EX1

[Paul Newman]

I've been testing the various files available on DV Info using the Sony browswer software to export as .mxf files and then into Edius. I'm running an NX card with component HD out to a JVC 19" Tube HD monitor, and a JVC 26" HD flatscreen ( also component HD in )

Initial tests down converting a 1920x1080 50i project to SD PAL ( EX1 HQ 35mb 1920x1080 50i file ) have pretty alarming "jaggies" worse than seen with Z1's - looks as though we may need some improved software to handle the finer detail from the +2M pixel chips in the EX1.

Interestingly, I'm seeing higher detail than I'm used to from XDCAM HD (350)
files.

I wonder if the detail setup in the EX1 is a little hot in default mode?

I'll put some stills on my server today if time allows.

Paul

[Kevin Shaw]

Originally Posted by Paul Newman

I've been testing the various files available on DV Info using the Sony browswer software to export as .mxf files and then into Edius. I'm running an NX card with component HD out to a JVC 19" Tube HD monitor, and a JVC 26" HD flatscreen ( also component HD in )

Initial tests down converting a 1920x1080 50i project to SD PAL ( EX1 HQ 35mb 1920x1080 50i file ) have pretty alarming "jaggies" worse than seen with Z1's - looks as though we may need some improved software to handle the finer detail from the +2M pixel chips in the EX1.

Edius has had issues in the past downconverting from HD to SD, so that may account for some of the issues you're seeing. Try changing the project setting to widescreen DV before doing the SD render and see if that helps.

[Andreas Johansson]

I haven't tried it much but this seems to work for me using ffmpeg

EX1.mp4 to DV25 (no need to unwrap in Clip Browser).
ffmpeg –i inputfile.mp4 –f dv –s 720x576 output.dv

[Peter Kraft]

Originally Posted by Paul Newman

Initial tests down converting a 1920x1080 50i project to SD PAL ( EX1 HQ 35mb 1920x1080 50i file ) have pretty alarming "jaggies" worse than seen with Z1's - looks as though we may need some improved software to handle the finer detail from the +2M pixel chips in the EX1.
...

I'll put some stills on my server today if time allows.

Paul, this is a quite normal effect, switching from progressive (HD) to interlaced (SD/PAL). You won't see the jaggies checking the SD file on a tube monitor, however they are visible on an LCD. One way to circumvent this is to de-interlace the SD video with an application like DVMaker or the likes.
DVMaker is worth every cent of its price as it re-renders the two interlaced frames into one progressive frame again without loosing resolution.

Would you care to post the stills on your server? Thanx.

BTW, hows to weather down at Ibiza?

[Matt San]

After a lot of looking about I have found the best way to get High quality MPEG-2 (dvd standard) files from my EX1

The application MediaCoder (latest beta) uses FFMPEG at it core but has a nice GUI.

check it out and see what you think

MediaCoder - more than a universal audio/video transcoder