Problems with Final Cut Pro's Log and Transfer tool at DVinfo.net

Adam Welz · April 13th, 2010, 01:08 PM

Hi All

I've done a simple summary of these (serious) issues, and presented a few workarounds, on my blog. Anyone planning to shoot on the NXCAM and use FCP should read it.

Ingesting AVCHD footage: Problems with Final Cut Pro’s Log and Transfer tool Adam Welz's NXCAM Blog

Your comments and additions welcome!

Adam

John Vasey · April 13th, 2010, 10:42 PM

Hi, Adam...

I met with Juan Martinez of Sony at NAB on Monday to discuss the NX5U issues with FCP. They made it very clear to me that as they see it, this is Apple's issue...and Apple will most likely need to release a patch to Log and Transfer.

I sense from their response that the problem is where this falls in Apple's "to do" list. Since the NX5U has a small user base for the moment, Apple will probably only deal with it after repeated knocks on their door. My hunch is that it will take almost half a year to get this recognized by Apple and then have them respond to it.

One alternate suggestion offered up was to use Cineform and it's wavelet-based codec. Another might be to use MPEG Streamclip to convert to Pro Res.

And yes, like you and many others, I wish Apple and Sony had tested out the AVCHD workflow for Final Cut Pro users ahead of time so these issued could have been avoided.

John

Adam Welz · April 14th, 2010, 03:55 PM

Hi John

I'm not enough of a boffin to know exactly what a wavelet-based codec is, and don't have the time right now to figure it out (shooting hours and hours every day) but Juan suggested Cineform to me too. It seems to cost $150, tho -- why should we have to be paying extra to make stuff work like they said it would? urgh!

Anyway, am still loving the images coming out of my NXCAM -- not quite up there with EX stuff in terms of slickness, but they have more character/a little grain, which I like. There are some dumb design decisions on the cam and some missing features that could easily be fixed with a firmware update, so here's hoping that in 6 months we'll have FCP and the NX5's software/firmware fixed! The basics are all there -- they just need tweaking!

Adam

April 13th, 2010, 01:08 PM	#1
Adam Welz Regular Crew Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: New York, USA Posts: 111	Problems with Final Cut Pro's Log and Transfer tool Hi All I've done a simple summary of these (serious) issues, and presented a few workarounds, on my blog. Anyone planning to shoot on the NXCAM and use FCP should read it. Ingesting AVCHD footage: Problems with Final Cut Pro’s Log and Transfer tool Adam Welz's NXCAM Blog Your comments and additions welcome! Adam

April 13th, 2010, 10:42 PM	#2
John Vasey Regular Crew Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Los Angeles, CA Posts: 75	Sony at NAB and their response... Hi, Adam... I met with Juan Martinez of Sony at NAB on Monday to discuss the NX5U issues with FCP. They made it very clear to me that as they see it, this is Apple's issue...and Apple will most likely need to release a patch to Log and Transfer. I sense from their response that the problem is where this falls in Apple's "to do" list. Since the NX5U has a small user base for the moment, Apple will probably only deal with it after repeated knocks on their door. My hunch is that it will take almost half a year to get this recognized by Apple and then have them respond to it. One alternate suggestion offered up was to use Cineform and it's wavelet-based codec. Another might be to use MPEG Streamclip to convert to Pro Res. And yes, like you and many others, I wish Apple and Sony had tested out the AVCHD workflow for Final Cut Pro users ahead of time so these issued could have been avoided. John

April 14th, 2010, 03:55 PM	#3
Adam Welz Regular Crew Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: New York, USA Posts: 111	Hi John I'm not enough of a boffin to know exactly what a wavelet-based codec is, and don't have the time right now to figure it out (shooting hours and hours every day) but Juan suggested Cineform to me too. It seems to cost $150, tho -- why should we have to be paying extra to make stuff work like they said it would? urgh! Anyway, am still loving the images coming out of my NXCAM -- not quite up there with EX stuff in terms of slickness, but they have more character/a little grain, which I like. There are some dumb design decisions on the cam and some missing features that could easily be fixed with a firmware update, so here's hoping that in 6 months we'll have FCP and the NX5's software/firmware fixed! The basics are all there -- they just need tweaking! Adam