What to buy - HDRFX7 or HVR-V1U

[Jason Donaldson]

Hi guys,

I am new to videography, and recently begun shooting weddings etc. I purchased a Sony HVR-A1U, and am liking it alot. Haven't had any complaints with it so far, except for low lighting capabilities, but my HVL-20DW2 solves that pretty well. I recently received good news that my business loan app was approaved, so I am going to be going shopping for some equipment. My local camera shop (Henrys in Canada) was where I bought my A1U for $2999.00CAD. Here is my question:

Should I buy the HDRFX7,
http://www.henrys.com/webapp/wcs/sto...&sortKey=price

which right now at Henrys is on for $3499CAD, $1100 off the retail price, or should I just splurge and go for the HVR-V1U,
http://www.henrys.com/webapp/wcs/sto...&sortKey=price

on for $4999CAD

Or are there other models I should be looking at. I would like to buy another unti, and keep the A1U for static podium filming.

Any input is appriciated, but keep in mind this $ is burning a hole in my pocket....lol

[Leslie Wand]

i think my v1 is a great piece of equipment - but it's really not suited to low-light environments.

leslie

[Serena Steuart]

A good general rule is to always buy the more professional version if the budget allows. Another is not to be decoyed by an apparent bargain from making a careful decision! In terms of low light performance, the smaller the sensor pixels the less sensitive (think of them as buckets collecting photons). You need to identify your working requirements and check off cameras against them. All the HDV cameras suffer somewhat in low light conditions; you must also consider inherent noise level because that's what you amplify when using higher video gain. The Z1, for example, performs acceptably at 18dB gain provided your lighting is high key and don't have to push the image further in post (visible noise in low light areas, very like film grain). Pay attention to lens quality; does it go wide enough without attachments; what is the zoom range at maximum aperture (important when in low light); does it hold focus when zooming (manual focus). How easy is the camera to use under frenetic circumstances.
And you'll be doing more than weddings in low light, so think through your global needs.

[John Bosco Jr.]

Since you do have a camera light at your disposal, the V1 or FX7 will work fine. If you don't plan to do 24p, then go with the FX7. Is this going to be your main camera, and your A1 the backup or 2nd camera? If that's the case, then the FX7 or V1 will work just fine. If you can fit it in your budget, the V1 is a very nice camera. You also might want to take a look at the Canon XHA1 (a wider lens and good price).

Good luck

[Jack Walker]

As said above, you might look at the XH-A1. It has the professional features at a very good price.

Also, of the several cameras in this category, the XH-A1 seems to be the better in low light (though none of them will compete with the SD PD150/170)

You might ask in the XH-A1 forum how that camera would suit your purpose as compared to the V1.

[Craig Irving]

I love the form factor and weight of the V1U, and I've always liked Sony's menus & ergonomics. I would go with the V1U now that the price has just dropped.

You can buy it for $4899 from Vistek.ca (or if there's a location in Ottawa).

[Jason Donaldson]

Thanks for all the replies guys. I think I have chosen to go with the extra money on the V1U. I think with the use of another HVL-20DW2 it will do just as good or better as my A1U in low light .

[Vaughan Wood]

I would strongly suggest investigating the soon to be released Sony XDCam EX if you are going to shoot weddings, as it has 1/2 sensor and should be much better in low light than my FX 7 (even with the new Sony light HVL-LBP).

You will definitely struggle with your 10/20 light.

Cheers Vaughan