What software for edits and blu ray. at DVinfo.net

Alexander Oosterbaan · October 8th, 2009, 07:44 PM

Hi all,

I've been reading posts for a while and learned a lot so far. I am a newbie in the HD world but I am ready to learn. I bought a HMC151 3 weeks ago (I needed the pal and ntsc option) and a new editing PC with the works.
But life hasn't been so good the past few days!!!!
I love the camera. I still need to get used to all the options, but that will come with time. What I just can't stand is the editing process. Untill now I have tryed multiple editing programs, but somehow they all fail!
Vegas studio 9 pro hangs when creating a movie longer than 35 minutes.
Pinnacle studio 12 is a bit too consumer orientated. It created a blue ray disk but only needed 3,5 GB for 45 min of full HD 1080i movie. The result was not great, but at least the disk played on a BR player :)
I have Edius and Premiere CS4 left to try.

Can someone tell me which of these programs works best, and what setting I should use for best quality files and blu ray movies?

Thank you,

Alex.

Paul Digges · October 9th, 2009, 05:12 PM

I think you'll find your best bet in CS4, as it does support AVCHD. I've been using Premiere since the version right before Pro, so 6.5 I think? If you end up grabbing it as the whole suite, all the programs integrate wonderfully, and After Effects is an incredibly powerful program. Also Encore is a super intuitive Authoring program.

Good luck with whatever you wind up using though.

October 8th, 2009, 07:44 PM	#1
Alexander Oosterbaan New Boot Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: Beavercreek Ohio Posts: 6	What software for edits and blu ray. Hi all, I've been reading posts for a while and learned a lot so far. I am a newbie in the HD world but I am ready to learn. I bought a HMC151 3 weeks ago (I needed the pal and ntsc option) and a new editing PC with the works. But life hasn't been so good the past few days!!!! I love the camera. I still need to get used to all the options, but that will come with time. What I just can't stand is the editing process. Untill now I have tryed multiple editing programs, but somehow they all fail! Vegas studio 9 pro hangs when creating a movie longer than 35 minutes. Pinnacle studio 12 is a bit too consumer orientated. It created a blue ray disk but only needed 3,5 GB for 45 min of full HD 1080i movie. The result was not great, but at least the disk played on a BR player :) I have Edius and Premiere CS4 left to try. Can someone tell me which of these programs works best, and what setting I should use for best quality files and blu ray movies? Thank you, Alex.

October 9th, 2009, 05:12 PM	#2
Paul Digges Regular Crew Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Phoenix, AZ Posts: 153	I think you'll find your best bet in CS4, as it does support AVCHD. I've been using Premiere since the version right before Pro, so 6.5 I think? If you end up grabbing it as the whole suite, all the programs integrate wonderfully, and After Effects is an incredibly powerful program. Also Encore is a super intuitive Authoring program. Good luck with whatever you wind up using though.