Post production for JVC Pro HD camcorders? at DVinfo.net

Adam Grunseth · January 13th, 2008, 03:10 AM

My workstation died. It was old, having problems, and finally took its last breath, laid down, and died. So, obviously now I am in the position of replacing my workstation. Originally I was going to install the same software, Edius 4. I haven't been exactly happy with Edius though.... it doesn't provide many built in compositing tools, and your limited with how you can combine effects. More importantly, on longer projects that do include lots of effects it seems to have stability issues. Unfortunately I don't have the money to invest in all new software as well as a new workstation.

Then I discovered linux. More specifically Ubuntu Studio (http://ubuntustudio.org/) It supposedly comes complete with everything you need for multimedia production, including pro audio, graphics, editing, and compositing applications. I am curious if anyone here has any experience using a linux based post production workflow? I know some of the industry's most powerful tools- da vinci color correctors and discreets high end finishing products are all linux exclusive, but I'm not sure if open source software is up to the task.

The main video editing application is Cinelerra (http://heroinewarrior.com/cinelerra10.php3). Has anyone used this program with the JVC and what were the results?

Earl Thurston · January 14th, 2008, 01:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Adam Grunseth

...Ubuntu Studio. It supposedly comes complete with everything you need for multimedia production, including pro audio, graphics, editing, and compositing applications. I am curious if anyone here has any experience using a linux based post production workflow?

I looked at Ubuntu Studio myself recently, and found it woefully inadequate for video production as-is. Most of the bundled apps are geared towards audio production, and the few video production utilities are primitive at best.

The general state of FOSS and affordable commercial Linux software for video production is lacking right now, particularly at market level you find Premiere, Final Cut, Edius, Vegas, etc. MainConcept's MainActor was about the closest thing you could find but it has been discontinued. (Even then, it was only about as advanced as Premiere Elements.)

Cinelerra is so heavily system specific, biased towards the needs of its original programmers, few people can make use of it without a lot of tinkering. And everything else is in the stratospheric, multi-thousand-dollar professional range.

I'd love to switch to Linux myself, but regrettably can't.

January 13th, 2008, 03:10 AM	#1
Adam Grunseth Major Player Join Date: May 2005 Location: Eugene Oregon Posts: 393	Post production for JVC Pro HD camcorders? My workstation died. It was old, having problems, and finally took its last breath, laid down, and died. So, obviously now I am in the position of replacing my workstation. Originally I was going to install the same software, Edius 4. I haven't been exactly happy with Edius though.... it doesn't provide many built in compositing tools, and your limited with how you can combine effects. More importantly, on longer projects that do include lots of effects it seems to have stability issues. Unfortunately I don't have the money to invest in all new software as well as a new workstation. Then I discovered linux. More specifically Ubuntu Studio (http://ubuntustudio.org/) It supposedly comes complete with everything you need for multimedia production, including pro audio, graphics, editing, and compositing applications. I am curious if anyone here has any experience using a linux based post production workflow? I know some of the industry's most powerful tools- da vinci color correctors and discreets high end finishing products are all linux exclusive, but I'm not sure if open source software is up to the task. The main video editing application is Cinelerra (http://heroinewarrior.com/cinelerra10.php3). Has anyone used this program with the JVC and what were the results?