Monitor configuration, asking for personel opinions. at DVinfo.net

Jeff Troiano · January 29th, 2011, 11:12 PM

Ok, have my Mac Pro, and FC studio. In the process of setting up the rest of the system. Its eventually going to be a general purpose system, editing, photo, modeling, effects, and maybe some sound, all thrown in together. I have a whole shopping list of things I want to get to complete things. I've built, and worked with multi monitor systems (Night club DJ systems), and will be running a mutli monitor system here. I'm pretty sure I've decided on Dell Ultra sharp monitors. These will be general purpose monitors (not color grading).

BUT!! (there's always a but), My shopping list priority allows me a certain amount, at this time for this. So I could get two 24 inch (16:10, 1900x1200) ultra sharp.

Or I could get one 27 inch (16:9, 2560x1440), or possible save a little more and get one 30 inch (16:10, 2560x1600)

If I go the single monitor route, it may be 6 to 8 months, before my budget will allow the 2nd monitor. I have a crappy 19 inch lcd, that I can use, if I needed too, but it isnt that good.

I was just like to hear some opinions, about your work flow, and what you think about screen sizes, for FCP and the other applications you use. I know there is a monitor forum, but since FCP in my focus, I wanted to ask some fcp people their thoughts.

Thanks,
Jeff

Craig Parkes · January 31st, 2011, 11:12 AM

Physical desk real-estate is something you should consider - but ignoring that for the moment, assuming you aren't also monitoring out to an external broadcast monitor/plasma etc for playback then two 24" obviously a good option - the issue being at 1900 pixels wide you aren't quite full HD, which is what you really want to have on your viewing monitor if you are going to be working in HD resolutions.

However, if you only have one decently sized screen, then you can't monitor at full res (using Digital Cinema Desktop) and edit on the timeline anyway - so my advise would be to try and spring for some screens that will definitely do full raster HD if possible (1920 width.)

The crappy 19" monitor is actually quite useful, because you can just use it for bins, and use your main monitor as the timeline etc. This again works best if you are viewing the footage and timeline on an external video monitor of some sort, and not on you computer screen.

Andrew Hughes · January 31st, 2011, 01:34 PM

Just FYI: we bought 4 Dell U2410f 24" monitors and we've had to send 3 of them back. To Dell's credit, they've shipped us replacement monitors immediately, but still.

Jeff Troiano · January 31st, 2011, 04:15 PM

I really do want to get a couple 27 or 30 inch monitors. Eventually my setup with be multiple main screens (thru my ati vid card). Then I want to output, via a Kona card (or something like that), to a broadcast monitor, and a plasma.

If not the dells, would anyone have a brand recommendation for these monitors? I've seen both good and bad about the Dell ultra's. I want two screens with nice sharp pictures, and decent color reproductions.

Thanks,
Jeff

Caleb Reynolds · February 1st, 2011, 07:42 AM

samsung has some fairly newer 20-24in led monitors that I like. They run about 270 a piece. I would think that would be in your budget since your looking into 27in+

Nigel Barker · February 4th, 2011, 05:07 PM

There really is no substitute for one socking great monitor that gives you the largest amount of screen real estate in one device. I know that two 16:10 24" monitors have a larger total pixel count but it's not the same. If you get one good 30" monitor you can always get a cheapish 24" or 2 for non critical usage (web browsing, email etc) for use alongside the 2560x1600 monster.

January 29th, 2011, 11:12 PM	#1
Jeff Troiano Major Player Join Date: May 2003 Location: Nashville TN Posts: 480	Monitor configuration, asking for personel opinions. Ok, have my Mac Pro, and FC studio. In the process of setting up the rest of the system. Its eventually going to be a general purpose system, editing, photo, modeling, effects, and maybe some sound, all thrown in together. I have a whole shopping list of things I want to get to complete things. I've built, and worked with multi monitor systems (Night club DJ systems), and will be running a mutli monitor system here. I'm pretty sure I've decided on Dell Ultra sharp monitors. These will be general purpose monitors (not color grading). BUT!! (there's always a but), My shopping list priority allows me a certain amount, at this time for this. So I could get two 24 inch (16:10, 1900x1200) ultra sharp. Or I could get one 27 inch (16:9, 2560x1440), or possible save a little more and get one 30 inch (16:10, 2560x1600) If I go the single monitor route, it may be 6 to 8 months, before my budget will allow the 2nd monitor. I have a crappy 19 inch lcd, that I can use, if I needed too, but it isnt that good. I was just like to hear some opinions, about your work flow, and what you think about screen sizes, for FCP and the other applications you use. I know there is a monitor forum, but since FCP in my focus, I wanted to ask some fcp people their thoughts. Thanks, Jeff

January 31st, 2011, 11:12 AM	#2
Craig Parkes Major Player Join Date: Dec 2006 Location: Auckland, New Zealand Posts: 444	Physical desk real-estate is something you should consider - but ignoring that for the moment, assuming you aren't also monitoring out to an external broadcast monitor/plasma etc for playback then two 24" obviously a good option - the issue being at 1900 pixels wide you aren't quite full HD, which is what you really want to have on your viewing monitor if you are going to be working in HD resolutions. However, if you only have one decently sized screen, then you can't monitor at full res (using Digital Cinema Desktop) and edit on the timeline anyway - so my advise would be to try and spring for some screens that will definitely do full raster HD if possible (1920 width.) The crappy 19" monitor is actually quite useful, because you can just use it for bins, and use your main monitor as the timeline etc. This again works best if you are viewing the footage and timeline on an external video monitor of some sort, and not on you computer screen. __________________ www.afterglow.co.nz

February 1st, 2011, 07:42 AM	#5
Caleb Reynolds Regular Crew Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Austin, Texas Posts: 113	samsung has some fairly newer 20-24in led monitors that I like. They run about 270 a piece. I would think that would be in your budget since your looking into 27in+ __________________ www.TeamKProductions.com Twitter Facebook

January 31st, 2011, 01:34 PM	#3
Andrew Hughes Regular Crew Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Austin, TX Posts: 48	Just FYI: we bought 4 Dell U2410f 24" monitors and we've had to send 3 of them back. To Dell's credit, they've shipped us replacement monitors immediately, but still.

January 31st, 2011, 04:15 PM	#4
Jeff Troiano Major Player Join Date: May 2003 Location: Nashville TN Posts: 480	I really do want to get a couple 27 or 30 inch monitors. Eventually my setup with be multiple main screens (thru my ati vid card). Then I want to output, via a Kona card (or something like that), to a broadcast monitor, and a plasma. If not the dells, would anyone have a brand recommendation for these monitors? I've seen both good and bad about the Dell ultra's. I want two screens with nice sharp pictures, and decent color reproductions. Thanks, Jeff

February 4th, 2011, 05:07 PM	#6
Nigel Barker Inner Circle Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Norwich, Norfolk, UK Posts: 3,531	There really is no substitute for one socking great monitor that gives you the largest amount of screen real estate in one device. I know that two 16:10 24" monitors have a larger total pixel count but it's not the same. If you get one good 30" monitor you can always get a cheapish 24" or 2 for non critical usage (web browsing, email etc) for use alongside the 2560x1600 monster.