Out of sync in viewer/timeline, but not final render or quicktime at DVinfo.net

Nils Hoover · October 20th, 2010, 09:22 AM

Out of sync in viewer/timeline, but not final render or quicktime

Working with the standard def DV codec, and have a file which appears out of sync in the timeline, and in the viewer, but it is perfectly in sync viewed in quicktime.

It seems to be the video that is drifting, rather than the audio, as I used a piece of video from the file and when I rendered it, the video has slipped and was the wrong clip (but from close by).

Shot and editing in 24p

In the past I have just recaptured, but it never seems to be a guarantee. I have had this problem a lot, and never fully understood it why, always just going back to make sure that we were capturing the footage correctly (we have been capturing with a cheap camera that has given us problems, but I don't know if that is it).

Allen White · October 22nd, 2010, 11:36 PM

SD doesn't have perfect image & audio sync, and shooting or capturing on a cheap camera might exaggerate the sync loss. I just used to slip the footage back into sync. It's typically only a few frames off, so if your sync is greater, you may have some kind of other issue.

If your lack of sync gets gradually worse over the course of the video, your audio may be playing back at 44100 KHz instead of 48000. Check the clip's audio setting in your browser. This would explain why it would play fine in Quicktime and not in FCP. (Maybe the default for this setting was changed in your Sequence Settings, or your Audio/Video settings under A/V devices.)

October 20th, 2010, 09:22 AM	#1
Nils Hoover Regular Crew Join Date: Feb 2006 Location: ithaca ny Posts: 57	Out of sync in viewer/timeline, but not final render or quicktime Out of sync in viewer/timeline, but not final render or quicktime Working with the standard def DV codec, and have a file which appears out of sync in the timeline, and in the viewer, but it is perfectly in sync viewed in quicktime. It seems to be the video that is drifting, rather than the audio, as I used a piece of video from the file and when I rendered it, the video has slipped and was the wrong clip (but from close by). Shot and editing in 24p In the past I have just recaptured, but it never seems to be a guarantee. I have had this problem a lot, and never fully understood it why, always just going back to make sure that we were capturing the footage correctly (we have been capturing with a cheap camera that has given us problems, but I don't know if that is it). __________________ http://nils.tv www.vimeo.com/nilz

October 22nd, 2010, 11:36 PM	#2
Allen White Regular Crew Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: San Francisco, CA Posts: 60	SD doesn't have perfect image & audio sync, and shooting or capturing on a cheap camera might exaggerate the sync loss. I just used to slip the footage back into sync. It's typically only a few frames off, so if your sync is greater, you may have some kind of other issue. If your lack of sync gets gradually worse over the course of the video, your audio may be playing back at 44100 KHz instead of 48000. Check the clip's audio setting in your browser. This would explain why it would play fine in Quicktime and not in FCP. (Maybe the default for this setting was changed in your Sequence Settings, or your Audio/Video settings under A/V devices.)