Adobe or FCP at DVinfo.net

Don Bazley · July 2nd, 2008, 09:17 AM

I bought a MacBook Pro yesterday. I also bought FCP but I haven't opened or installed it. I used to hate Premier back in the day but I have been teaching it for years now and I think that now that they've made improvements over they years the Adobe products can do just about anything. Since I am already VERY accustomed to the work flow and I already own Adobe (so I can save $$$ by just upgrading) I'm thinking of going with Adobe for the Mac.

I considered running Windows XP and upgrading Adobe but I decided against that. When I loaded Windows and saw it on the Mac I felt like I had killed the Mac. :)

Any thoughts on why I may want to keep FCP over PremierCS3 ?

Most of my work is weddings and training videos. Most effects are color correction and slo-mo.

-Don B.

Mike Barber · July 2nd, 2008, 09:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Don Bazley

Since I am already VERY accustomed to the work flow and I already own Adobe

I think your answer is in there.

I'm not familiar with Premier, but similarly to the "Avid vs. Final Cut" argument it really comes down to which is the best tool for you?

Don Bazley · July 2nd, 2008, 01:33 PM

Thanks for the input. I think that all the editors have progressed so much (I started on Avid in early '90s) that they are all pretty similar now and it mostly depends what you'r comfortable with. I was just curious if there were any specific reasons I'd want FCP over CS3.

I hope you are enjoying Jazz Fest. I love Montreal. Merci.

-Don B.

Martin Mayer · July 2nd, 2008, 01:51 PM

I suggest you read this thread on the DVdoctor Mac forum. The trouble is: (as you say yourself) you're familiar with the Adobe workflow... so why don't you just use a PC?

(BTW: In case anyone thinks I'm Mac-bashing: I'm not - I'm actually a Mac-fan and Mac-user, but I also believe in using what you know, and not repeating others' mistakes.)

Robert Lane · July 2nd, 2008, 02:07 PM

You'd be much better off staying with the Adobe products because of your experience with them and, purchasing FCS2 would be re-inventing the wheel with regard to the learning curve.

Plus, the PP CS3 apps are integrated between each other much more intuitively than FCS2 is currently (something we hope will change with FCS3) and PP CS3 will handle the type of work you do perfectly.

The only reason (for you) to consider FCS2 would be if you were entering into the broadcast/film/commercial markets and needed to interface with other FCP editors or have access to more professional codecs than PP CS3 currently handles.

Don Bazley · July 2nd, 2008, 03:03 PM

Thanks for the input everyone. The points Robert makes are sort of where I'm coming from. HOWEVER... the link that Martin posted really has me wondering.

I only wanted a Mac for (supposed) better performance/reliability (no intention of platform rants here). I'm on the fence. If FCP truly runs much better on a Mac than Premier will, I may keep the FCP and deal with some learning. I've never had a problem with Encore and I actually have come to like the menu layout functions of it.

I'm headed out for a few days and I'll check back for other posts on Monday. Thanks for the input so far.

-Don

July 2nd, 2008, 09:17 AM	#1
Don Bazley Regular Crew Join Date: Dec 2001 Location: Ithaca, NY Posts: 149	Adobe or FCP I bought a MacBook Pro yesterday. I also bought FCP but I haven't opened or installed it. I used to hate Premier back in the day but I have been teaching it for years now and I think that now that they've made improvements over they years the Adobe products can do just about anything. Since I am already VERY accustomed to the work flow and I already own Adobe (so I can save $$$ by just upgrading) I'm thinking of going with Adobe for the Mac. I considered running Windows XP and upgrading Adobe but I decided against that. When I loaded Windows and saw it on the Mac I felt like I had killed the Mac. :) Any thoughts on why I may want to keep FCP over PremierCS3 ? Most of my work is weddings and training videos. Most effects are color correction and slo-mo. -Don B. __________________ "When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro" - Hunter S. Thompson

July 2nd, 2008, 01:33 PM	#3
Don Bazley Regular Crew Join Date: Dec 2001 Location: Ithaca, NY Posts: 149	Thanks for the input. I think that all the editors have progressed so much (I started on Avid in early '90s) that they are all pretty similar now and it mostly depends what you'r comfortable with. I was just curious if there were any specific reasons I'd want FCP over CS3. I hope you are enjoying Jazz Fest. I love Montreal. Merci. -Don B. __________________ "When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro" - Hunter S. Thompson

July 2nd, 2008, 01:51 PM	#4
Martin Mayer Major Player Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Oxfordshire, UK Posts: 416	I suggest you read this thread on the DVdoctor Mac forum. The trouble is: (as you say yourself) you're familiar with the Adobe workflow... so why don't you just use a PC? (BTW: In case anyone thinks I'm Mac-bashing: I'm not - I'm actually a Mac-fan and Mac-user, but I also believe in using what you know, and not repeating others' mistakes.) __________________ Martin at HeadSpin HD on Blu-ray

July 2nd, 2008, 03:03 PM	#6
Don Bazley Regular Crew Join Date: Dec 2001 Location: Ithaca, NY Posts: 149	Thanks for the input everyone. The points Robert makes are sort of where I'm coming from. HOWEVER... the link that Martin posted really has me wondering. I only wanted a Mac for (supposed) better performance/reliability (no intention of platform rants here). I'm on the fence. If FCP truly runs much better on a Mac than Premier will, I may keep the FCP and deal with some learning. I've never had a problem with Encore and I actually have come to like the menu layout functions of it. I'm headed out for a few days and I'll check back for other posts on Monday. Thanks for the input so far. -Don __________________ "When the going gets weird, the weird turn pro" - Hunter S. Thompson

July 2nd, 2008, 02:07 PM	#5
Robert Lane Go Go Godzilla Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: Scottsdale, AZ USA Posts: 2,823 Images: 15	You'd be much better off staying with the Adobe products because of your experience with them and, purchasing FCS2 would be re-inventing the wheel with regard to the learning curve. Plus, the PP CS3 apps are integrated between each other much more intuitively than FCS2 is currently (something we hope will change with FCS3) and PP CS3 will handle the type of work you do perfectly. The only reason (for you) to consider FCS2 would be if you were entering into the broadcast/film/commercial markets and needed to interface with other FCP editors or have access to more professional codecs than PP CS3 currently handles.