horizontal banding in noise at DVinfo.net

Kris Bird · April 19th, 2007, 05:33 AM

Can someone with an xh-a1 close their iris entirely (or put lens cap on) and set gain to 36db ... the noise on my unit is a grey and noisy, but if I leave the unit on like this for half an hour, the image gradually gets more and more "banded" and stroby .. as in, strobing horizontal noisy lines, like analogue interference I suppose. This increase in visible "banding" patterns seems to correspond to the bottom of the A1 getting warm .... As it heats up (and gets worse), it gradually becomes slightly apparent in lower and lower gain levels ...

Is this normal? Or should I return the unit?

Don Palomaki · April 19th, 2007, 06:25 AM

Is this an issue that you can see with normal use of the camcorder, or just when shooting the inside of the lens cap at 36 dB gain for 30 minutes or more? 36 dB is a lot of gain, about 64x or 6-stops in film speak.

The noise from the CCD (as well as noise in other analog circuits) is in part thermally generated noise. As the CCD (and other analog circuits) warm up you can expect the thermal noise component to increase with temperature, and if part of the CCD is warmer (a thermal gradient across it), its noise level may be higher at one side than the other. I suppose the thermal gradient might cause other high gain image artifacts as a result of how the CCDs are read as well.

It is probably a good part of why 36 dB gain is considered useless by many people and not found on many camcorders.

I can't say whether or not it is normal for the XH-A1, or any other camcorder for that matter - I've never tried that test or heard of anyone else doing it. If the camcorder serves you well for your normal shooting, you can monitor progress and make your final decision before warranty runs out. But if it causes you to loose sleep, return it.

Kris Bird · April 19th, 2007, 07:01 AM

After 30mins+ of being powered on, the horizontal strobing interference-like noise clearly visible at 12db, and faintly visible at even -3db. This is all tested in low to lowish light conditions.

The 36db test is interesting as you can clearly see the "flat" greyish noise gradually get more and more "banded", until it's a big mess of strobing bands after ~30mins... it is an exaggerated version of what I'm seeing subtle hints of at lower gain levels... I've never seen these 'patterns' in the noise of other cams before (xl1, xl2, pd170, etc).

Don Palomaki · April 19th, 2007, 07:56 AM

Is this on a monitor with live camcorder output or image recorded on tape?
HDV or SD mode?

Kris Bird · April 19th, 2007, 08:33 AM

DV and HDV, visible on camera plus through component out to 42" plasma .. NOT yet viewed on PC, as windows 2003 doesn't seem to play happy with the cam. Going to try capture on an XP box shortly...

Really I'd like someone to check their A1 to see if they have the same phenomenon, as if they don't then I'll try to get it replaced ...

But yeah, I'll try to get it captured asap .. currently in the middle of a 4-day edit/grade of a music vid, so a bit manic.

Don Palomaki · April 19th, 2007, 09:12 AM

What presets, if any, are in effect?

Kris Bird · April 19th, 2007, 09:20 AM

none, AGC (autogain) off, no noise reduction or anything ...

Eric Weiss · April 19th, 2007, 09:34 AM

crap. now my thirty-minute art film "lense cap in the dark at +36db" is totally ruined!

curse you canon!!!

Pete Bauer · April 19th, 2007, 09:40 AM

I'd suspect that Don's explanation is pretty much the story and that there is nothing faulty with the camera. The user manual will even caution that after the camera has been on for a while, manual focus needs to be checked because warming of the lens and circuitry can affect focus slightly.

Kris Bird · April 19th, 2007, 09:48 AM

Cheers for the answers so far, it's clear that I'm going to have to capture a sample movie at -3 and +12 gain (after the cam has been powered on for a while), as the fluttering 'interference' lines are unlike anything I've seen on any other digital cam .. almost like RF interference. It seems very faint at -3, while at +12 or higher there's intense strobing of horizontal bands.

I was expecting either, a) people know exactly what I'm talking about, as it's really quite visible, or b) no one knows what I'm talking about, so the cam must be faulty, as it's really quite visible ;)

David W. Jones · April 19th, 2007, 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kris Bird

Can someone with an xh-a1 close their iris entirely (or put lens cap on) and set gain to 36db ... the noise on my unit is a grey and noisy, but if I leave the unit on like this for half an hour, the image gradually gets more and more "banded" and stroby ..

Sorry, but No, I will not run my camera at +36 gain for a half an hour with the lens cap on to see if I encounter the same garbage.

Kind of like asking a man to run his parked Ferrari's engine at 9K RPM for a half an hour to see if it blows as well.

What is your whole point in this exercise...
I mean, have you shot any actual footage with the camera?

Khoi Pham · April 19th, 2007, 01:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David W. Jones

Sorry, but No, I will not run my camera at +36 gain for a half an hour with the lens cap on to see if I encounter the same garbage.

Kind of like asking a man to run his parked Ferrari's engine at 9K RPM for a half an hour to see if it blows as well.

What is your whole point in this exercise...
I mean, have you shot any actual footage with the camera?

Exactly, I think you have ruined it already since now you also see it at 12db, either that or your cable from the camera is near a power cord, that could introduced interference also, but I wonder what on earth made you do that in the first place? are you a UFO researcher?

Kris Bird · April 19th, 2007, 01:41 PM

I'm surprised that I've gotten such a negative response here, I don't see how I've explained this so colossally badly.

To re-iterate:-

- I'm getting a horizontal banding noise, like analogue interference
- It is not visible when I first turn the cam on
- It is worst after 30mins (turned on, not recording)
- Bottom of the cam gets warm to the touch
- It is very slightly visible at -3db, after being on for a while
- It looks like epileptic inducing strobing bands at 36db, once the cam has been on for a while
- There are strong visible banding noise at 12db, after the cam has been on for a while
- I've not seen it on the approx half a dozen pro cams I've owned.

What I've NOT said:-
- That I'm recording 36db for hours
- That I want anyone else to do the same
- That I want the camera to be usable at high gain

I've noticed a phenominon that affects all levels of gain, that is linked to how long the cam has been on, and that is 'extremely' visible at 36db, and becomes more subtle as you go down.

Since clearly no one knows what I'm on about..

looks like it's a fault.

Don Palomaki · April 19th, 2007, 07:48 PM

Can you capture a small sample bit of it; say from 36 dB and 12 dB and post it were we can see it. Maybe attach a frame grab if that works.

What, if any, kind of lighting is leaning thorugh the lens cap? Incandescent, Flourescent, daylight? What shutter speed

Lloyd Coleman · April 19th, 2007, 11:20 PM

Kris,

I set my A1 on manual with the gain at 36 dB. Of course I can see some noise, but not serious banding or strobing like you describe. After 30 minutes the noise is the same as when I started. At 18 dB I can barely see the noise and at 12 dB it is totally gone, even after being on for 30 minutes.

It is well know that the CCDs heat up with use and that the heat causes more noise, however, my camera did not get warm enough to feel or cause significantly more noise after 30 minutes. The bottom of my camera was not even warm to the touch on the bottom or anywhere else. I would suspect that there is a problem with your camera that is producing more heat than the CCDs alone and the extra heat is producing the noise that you are seeing.

April 19th, 2007, 05:33 AM	#1
Kris Bird Regular Crew Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 173	horizontal banding in noise Can someone with an xh-a1 close their iris entirely (or put lens cap on) and set gain to 36db ... the noise on my unit is a grey and noisy, but if I leave the unit on like this for half an hour, the image gradually gets more and more "banded" and stroby .. as in, strobing horizontal noisy lines, like analogue interference I suppose. This increase in visible "banding" patterns seems to correspond to the bottom of the A1 getting warm .... As it heats up (and gets worse), it gradually becomes slightly apparent in lower and lower gain levels ... Is this normal? Or should I return the unit?

April 19th, 2007, 06:25 AM	#2
Don Palomaki Wrangler Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: Northern VA Posts: 4,489	Is this an issue that you can see with normal use of the camcorder, or just when shooting the inside of the lens cap at 36 dB gain for 30 minutes or more? 36 dB is a lot of gain, about 64x or 6-stops in film speak. The noise from the CCD (as well as noise in other analog circuits) is in part thermally generated noise. As the CCD (and other analog circuits) warm up you can expect the thermal noise component to increase with temperature, and if part of the CCD is warmer (a thermal gradient across it), its noise level may be higher at one side than the other. I suppose the thermal gradient might cause other high gain image artifacts as a result of how the CCDs are read as well. It is probably a good part of why 36 dB gain is considered useless by many people and not found on many camcorders. I can't say whether or not it is normal for the XH-A1, or any other camcorder for that matter - I've never tried that test or heard of anyone else doing it. If the camcorder serves you well for your normal shooting, you can monitor progress and make your final decision before warranty runs out. But if it causes you to loose sleep, return it. __________________ dpalomaki@dspalomaki.com

April 19th, 2007, 07:56 AM	#4
Don Palomaki Wrangler Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: Northern VA Posts: 4,489	Is this on a monitor with live camcorder output or image recorded on tape? HDV or SD mode? __________________ dpalomaki@dspalomaki.com

April 19th, 2007, 09:12 AM	#6
Don Palomaki Wrangler Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: Northern VA Posts: 4,489	What presets, if any, are in effect? __________________ dpalomaki@dspalomaki.com

April 19th, 2007, 09:40 AM	#9
Pete Bauer Wrangler Join Date: May 2003 Location: Eagle River, AK Posts: 4,100	I'd suspect that Don's explanation is pretty much the story and that there is nothing faulty with the camera. The user manual will even caution that after the camera has been on for a while, manual focus needs to be checked because warming of the lens and circuitry can affect focus slightly. __________________ Pete Bauer The most beautiful thing we can experience is the mysterious. It is the source of all true art and science. Albert Einstein Trying to solve a DV mystery? You may find the answer behind the SEARCH function ... or be able to join a discussion already in progress!

April 19th, 2007, 07:01 AM	#3
Kris Bird Regular Crew Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 173	After 30mins+ of being powered on, the horizontal strobing interference-like noise clearly visible at 12db, and faintly visible at even -3db. This is all tested in low to lowish light conditions. The 36db test is interesting as you can clearly see the "flat" greyish noise gradually get more and more "banded", until it's a big mess of strobing bands after ~30mins... it is an exaggerated version of what I'm seeing subtle hints of at lower gain levels... I've never seen these 'patterns' in the noise of other cams before (xl1, xl2, pd170, etc).

April 19th, 2007, 08:33 AM	#5
Kris Bird Regular Crew Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 173	DV and HDV, visible on camera plus through component out to 42" plasma .. NOT yet viewed on PC, as windows 2003 doesn't seem to play happy with the cam. Going to try capture on an XP box shortly... Really I'd like someone to check their A1 to see if they have the same phenomenon, as if they don't then I'll try to get it replaced ... But yeah, I'll try to get it captured asap .. currently in the middle of a 4-day edit/grade of a music vid, so a bit manic.

April 19th, 2007, 09:20 AM	#7
Kris Bird Regular Crew Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 173	none, AGC (autogain) off, no noise reduction or anything ...

April 19th, 2007, 09:34 AM	#8
Eric Weiss Major Player Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Philly,PA Posts: 360	crap. now my thirty-minute art film "lense cap in the dark at +36db" is totally ruined! curse you canon!!!

April 19th, 2007, 09:48 AM	#10
Kris Bird Regular Crew Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 173	Cheers for the answers so far, it's clear that I'm going to have to capture a sample movie at -3 and +12 gain (after the cam has been powered on for a while), as the fluttering 'interference' lines are unlike anything I've seen on any other digital cam .. almost like RF interference. It seems very faint at -3, while at +12 or higher there's intense strobing of horizontal bands. I was expecting either, a) people know exactly what I'm talking about, as it's really quite visible, or b) no one knows what I'm talking about, so the cam must be faulty, as it's really quite visible ;)

April 19th, 2007, 01:41 PM	#13
Kris Bird Regular Crew Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: UK Posts: 173	I'm surprised that I've gotten such a negative response here, I don't see how I've explained this so colossally badly. To re-iterate:- - I'm getting a horizontal banding noise, like analogue interference - It is not visible when I first turn the cam on - It is worst after 30mins (turned on, not recording) - Bottom of the cam gets warm to the touch - It is very slightly visible at -3db, after being on for a while - It looks like epileptic inducing strobing bands at 36db, once the cam has been on for a while - There are strong visible banding noise at 12db, after the cam has been on for a while - I've not seen it on the approx half a dozen pro cams I've owned. What I've NOT said:- - That I'm recording 36db for hours - That I want anyone else to do the same - That I want the camera to be usable at high gain I've noticed a phenominon that affects all levels of gain, that is linked to how long the cam has been on, and that is 'extremely' visible at 36db, and becomes more subtle as you go down. Since clearly no one knows what I'm on about.. looks like it's a fault.

April 19th, 2007, 07:48 PM	#14
Don Palomaki Wrangler Join Date: Sep 2001 Location: Northern VA Posts: 4,489	Can you capture a small sample bit of it; say from 36 dB and 12 dB and post it were we can see it. Maybe attach a frame grab if that works. What, if any, kind of lighting is leaning thorugh the lens cap? Incandescent, Flourescent, daylight? What shutter speed __________________ dpalomaki@dspalomaki.com

April 19th, 2007, 11:20 PM	#15
Lloyd Coleman Major Player Join Date: Oct 2003 Location: Salt Lake City, UT Posts: 256	Kris, I set my A1 on manual with the gain at 36 dB. Of course I can see some noise, but not serious banding or strobing like you describe. After 30 minutes the noise is the same as when I started. At 18 dB I can barely see the noise and at 12 dB it is totally gone, even after being on for 30 minutes. It is well know that the CCDs heat up with use and that the heat causes more noise, however, my camera did not get warm enough to feel or cause significantly more noise after 30 minutes. The bottom of my camera was not even warm to the touch on the bottom or anywhere else. I would suspect that there is a problem with your camera that is producing more heat than the CCDs alone and the extra heat is producing the noise that you are seeing.