Hi All! Video Recording onto which SD Card?

[Sarge Hussain]

Hello All, I live in London UK, have just become a proud owner of a beautiful baby 550D, and just joined this wonderful forum :)

Many moons ago I used to make Wedding Films (from the early days of videos) but always wanted to get into Photography, but in those days it was all film and was a relatively expensive hobby so sadly never entered that arena.

I am new to SLR Photography and photography itself if I'm honest.

Questions are, When I record video I always prefer maximum quality setting as I do when taking pictures. Problem I see is when I playback the footage via mini usb through camera on Laptop it seems jerky, also I tried playing this footage in my PS3 directly from SDHC card with same results.

However playing back a few minutes of my son attempting to sing yesterday in the camera onto my tv seem a lot better but still jerky as if there is frame drop outs or the like happening.

The SDHC card I am using is Transcend 16GB SDHC.

My Canon 550D came with a 18-55mm lens. What lens's should be looking to buy and why please?


Cheers
Sarge

[Colin Rowe]

Class 6, or above

[Sarge Hussain]

Hi Thanks for reply, The Transcend 16GB I'm using is a Class 6. :(


Cheers
Sarge

[Burt Alcantara]

The Canon MOV files are processor intensive. I would first verify that they are running smoothly using the on-screen display. Once you verify that then you can assume all the other pieces are deficient in power.

Perhaps, it is time to upgrade your equipment to 64 bit with at least 2 GB RAM and at minimum, a dual-core processor. That should make a big difference. This video stuff is a money drain.

[Adrinn Chellton]

Welcome to the forums and I hope you enjoy the camera as well. As far as SDHC cards go the Transcend class 6 cards seem to work pretty well with T2i cameras. One recommendation would be to format your card every time you reuse it. This will help make sure the card works at it's rated speed and doesn't bog down on you.

[G. Lee Gordon]

IMHO. Ditch the class 6 card. Get class 10 cards(you can actually find them cheaper than glass 6 cards). 1st thing I would do is to check your shutter speed. It should be as close to double your frame rate, unless you are going for a special effect.

Next I would copy the files directly to your computer and see if that helps. If so, problem solved. Last but not least I am one of the few who likes the software provided by Canon. Try playing it with that.

As for lenses, there are a ton of post on that very question just search the site and you'll get so much information on which lenses to buy it will become clear as mud :)

good luck to ya.

[Sarge Hussain]

Thanks for your replies, I will investigate the card and pc equipment I am using, and get back to you. I was considering buying the Sandisk Extreme 16 or even 32gb, but can't justify the expense as yet and need to know if it absolutely critical to have one of these cards for both photo and the odd video or will the Transcends of this world work fine.

Also may I ask which lenses do you guys recommend and wouldn't be without please? for what purpose would each lens be and what costs would I be looking at? I have no idea on lenses .... STILL learning at aged 43 :)


Sarge

[James Donnelly]

Most people would say that the Canon EF 50mm f/1.8 is a good start.

Here is a good thread for background reading about lenses:

http://www.dvinfo.net/forum/canon-eo...-3-lenses.html

It's really worth spending the time reading.

[Bruce Foreman]

Originally Posted by Sarge Hussain

I was considering buying the Sandisk Extreme 16 or even 32gb, but can't justify the expense as yet and need to know if it absolutely critical to have one of these cards for both photo and the odd video or will the Transcends of this world work fine.
Sarge

Transcend cards don't fail as often as A-Data, Patriot, and other "bargain brands", but I have seen enough complaints of Transcend failing in several web forums to make me distrust that brand. When people run into "buffer overrun" problems and contact Canon techs they are often told the Canon camera can be a bit "brand picky" and are advised to use SanDisk Extreme III Class (6) or faster. Problems usually go away.

Kingston is a fairly good quality media brand but Kingston Class (6) cards have failed to keep up with the camera.

I would go for the SanDisk Extreme III or Extreme and if the expense is a put off you can use 8GB.

[Sarge Hussain]

Thanks Guys, I really do appreciate all the help/info from you Pro's. There is a sea of information available that I need to wade through but it seems so daunting and confusing.

Has anyone used some sort of lens to make a Anamorphic recording on a Canon 550D or similar? what about a Sony PD150 camcorder is this effect possible or is this a silly question :)

Please be gentle with me as I'm learning with great passion :)


Thanks

[Colin Rowe]

Originally Posted by Bruce Foreman

Transcend cards don't fail as often as A-Data, Patriot, and other "bargain brands", but I have seen enough complaints of Transcend failing in several web forums to make me distrust that brand. When people run into "buffer overrun" problems and contact Canon techs they are often told the Canon camera can be a bit "brand picky" and are advised to use SanDisk Extreme III Class (6) or faster. Problems usually go away.

Kingston is a fairly good quality media brand but Kingston Class (6) cards have failed to keep up with the camera.

I would go for the SanDisk Extreme III or Extreme and if the expense is a put off you can use 8GB.

I have been using Transcend class 6 cards for over a year in a Sony EX1, (as have many EX1 owners), no problems whatsoever. I recently purchased one of the new Transcend class 10 cards, again no problem. Lots of manufacturers will recommend various cards, it means little. Test the card of your choice, if it works, fine. Its difficult to get an objective opinion on card reliability, as various users report various pros and cons. I know of several people who swear by Kingstons in their 550D/7Ds, but they wouldn't dream of using the cards in an EX1. Try a Transcend 16gb class 10, they are available on Amazon for about £37 inc p&p. I dont think you will go far wrong.

[Christoffer Brekne]

The jerkiness in playback is most likely related to the box you use to playback.

Regarding SD cards, there are alot of sdhc cards with low classification that will work perfectly on the 550d - even class 2. The reason is that there are a number of categories a card needs to fulfill at set levels to recieve a given classification. Therefore a card can have a class 10 write speed for data transfer, but still be classified as class 2 if it falls short in other categories. Canon suggests using class 6 because the general minimum requirement for class 6 is a write speed of 6mbps or over. But several class 2 cards and class 4 cards I've tested perform well beyond the 5.5mbps limit of the Canon 550d. The cheap sandisk class 2 4gb sdhc performs as a class 10 card in write speed. I use cheap class 2 cards, and have had no problems. More about this here here.

[Sam Kanter]

Originally Posted by G. Lee Gordon

IMHO. Ditch the class 6 card. Get class 10 cards(you can actually find them cheaper than glass 6 cards). ]

good luck to ya.

I've used the Transcend class 6 cards for years with T1 and T2 - always performed flawlessly.

I would look somewhere else for solutions to issues.

[Sarge Hussain]

I have tried playback on my laptop, my Desktop and my son's PS3 (surely the PS3 would be quick enough?) The thing is I have also played back the video in the camera directly onto the tv and still get this problem, can't see what I'm doing wrong.

[Taky Cheung]

I ordered a few 32GB and 16GB class 6 Trensend card from Amazon. After careful consideration,I really cannot afford the risk of losing footage shot at weddings. I would just pay more to get six Sandisc 16GB class 6.