Audio Post Software at DVinfo.net

Steve House · July 15th, 2005, 10:41 AM

Looking for user input and experiences on the alternatives for audio software for post. Presently have access to both the Adobe suite (Audition with Premiere Pro) and Sony's (Vegas with SoundForge & Acid) to work with before making a final decision but looking for user feedback, comments, and comparisons with Nuendo or ProTools married to some other video NLE as well.

Don't anticipate any signifigant studio music recording but do want to be able to do general editing and sweetening of audio for DV, including dialog and music editing, quality location music recording, recording and editing of VO, ADR, foley, and FX. In other words, all around post-production recording, editing, and mixing tasks, primarily aimed at video / film-style video but also capable of quallity audio-only CD production.

Final output to be stereo tracks for DV or VHS tape, DVD in either stereo or surround, and music performance CDs. (Thinking here of scenarios such as shooting a recital and and being able to deliver both the video and a pro level audio CD of the performance to the client).

Nuendo and ProTools are both considerably more expensive than either Adobe or Sony - what do you get that's not in the other two, and is it worth the cost?

Rob Lohman · July 17th, 2005, 06:11 AM

Why not get some demos/trials of programs like Nuendo, ProTools and SoundForge?

Lot of these programs are a personal taste. ProTools is pretty much the industry
standard, of course.

I thought there was also a free version of ProTools (I checked, but couldn't
find it). I may be confused with Avid though.

Steve House · July 17th, 2005, 06:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rob Lohman

Why not get some demos/trials of programs like Nuendo, ProTools and SoundForge?

Lot of these programs are a personal taste. ProTools is pretty much the industry
standard, of course.

I thought there was also a free version of ProTools (I checked, but couldn't
find it). I may be confused with Avid though.

Of course - have SoundForge already but I like to add other's experiences to the mix as I plaly with the evals.

Devin Eskew · July 21st, 2005, 02:08 PM

I am not an audio expert, repeat I am not an audio expert. That being said, I have used Sound Forge for the past three years, and I just love how well it interacts with Vegas. Fixing and sweetening is quick and easy, just open your file in SF from Vegas remove noise whatever then save changes and they automaticly update your Vegas timeline. A few of the guys here at the college love Audition and wonder why I use an audio editor i.e. Vegas to cut video anyway, however the audio guys only use Sound Forge, and Sonar for audio. As for Pro Tools, our token mac guy just bought the plugin to use PT in FC-Pro, I'll ask him what he thinks.

Brian Handler · July 21st, 2005, 02:36 PM

I use logic pro at school a lot, seems pretty powerful. I only use it to the extent that audition works for me so unless your doing pretty hardcore stuff I think logic would be overkill.

July 15th, 2005, 10:41 AM	#1
Steve House Inner Circle Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Hamilton, Ontario, Canada Posts: 5,742	Audio Post Software Looking for user input and experiences on the alternatives for audio software for post. Presently have access to both the Adobe suite (Audition with Premiere Pro) and Sony's (Vegas with SoundForge & Acid) to work with before making a final decision but looking for user feedback, comments, and comparisons with Nuendo or ProTools married to some other video NLE as well. Don't anticipate any signifigant studio music recording but do want to be able to do general editing and sweetening of audio for DV, including dialog and music editing, quality location music recording, recording and editing of VO, ADR, foley, and FX. In other words, all around post-production recording, editing, and mixing tasks, primarily aimed at video / film-style video but also capable of quallity audio-only CD production. Final output to be stereo tracks for DV or VHS tape, DVD in either stereo or surround, and music performance CDs. (Thinking here of scenarios such as shooting a recital and and being able to deliver both the video and a pro level audio CD of the performance to the client). Nuendo and ProTools are both considerably more expensive than either Adobe or Sony - what do you get that's not in the other two, and is it worth the cost?

July 17th, 2005, 06:11 AM	#2
Rob Lohman RED Code Chef Join Date: Oct 2001 Location: Holland Posts: 12,514	Why not get some demos/trials of programs like Nuendo, ProTools and SoundForge? Lot of these programs are a personal taste. ProTools is pretty much the industry standard, of course. I thought there was also a free version of ProTools (I checked, but couldn't find it). I may be confused with Avid though. __________________ Rob Lohman, visuar@iname.com DV Info Wrangler & RED Code Chef Join the DV Challenge \| Lady X Search DVinfo.net for quick answers \| Buy from the best: DVinfo.net sponsors

July 21st, 2005, 02:08 PM	#4
Devin Eskew Regular Crew Join Date: Jul 2005 Location: Colorado Springs, CO Posts: 115	I am not an audio expert, repeat I am not an audio expert. That being said, I have used Sound Forge for the past three years, and I just love how well it interacts with Vegas. Fixing and sweetening is quick and easy, just open your file in SF from Vegas remove noise whatever then save changes and they automaticly update your Vegas timeline. A few of the guys here at the college love Audition and wonder why I use an audio editor i.e. Vegas to cut video anyway, however the audio guys only use Sound Forge, and Sonar for audio. As for Pro Tools, our token mac guy just bought the plugin to use PT in FC-Pro, I'll ask him what he thinks. __________________ We learn by doing, we learn better by making mistakes!

July 21st, 2005, 02:36 PM	#5
Brian Handler Regular Crew Join Date: Jun 2004 Location: Muncie Indiana Posts: 118	I use logic pro at school a lot, seems pretty powerful. I only use it to the extent that audition works for me so unless your doing pretty hardcore stuff I think logic would be overkill. __________________ Email me for projects in Ohio or Indiana. Lighting > Everything.