24p vs 25p, which one is more filmic?
 

Which one is more filmic: 24p or 25p? I live in Asia and will getting a Canon HV20 and it's (of course) going to be PAL version. Should I order NTSC version (24p) or is it ok with the PAL(25p)? Again, sorry for the dumb question =)

PAL is fine. As long as your distribution will be TV channels or DVD or digital projection you will be saving big bucks or time when not shooting in format that your native distribution channels don`t support by default. I live in Europe and any low budget project is done done in 25P rather than 24P even real 16mm and 35mm film projects are done in 25P for distribution`s sake. And if power outlets in your region are putting out 50hz power (and not 60hz like in NTSC land) you wont get that fluorescent flicker too.

Regs,
T

I record in 25p and then slow it down to 24p in Vegas (if I need 24p footage), the great thing is that in HD there is no need to change resolutions anymore, so its the same data just being played back a tad (4.1666 %) slower.

The human eye can't detect a difference between 24 and 25 frames per second. So it's not a question of which is more "filmic." Instead, it's really a question of workflow.

I agree with you. In fact, it's only noticeable if you switch between the original 25p and the slowed 24p, because of the audio tone shift (that could be fixed with a tonal correction filter).

That's what happen with all PAL DVD's, and even only a few have a tonal correction process, so... it's barely noticeable.

Right... take away the audio so it's visual only, and you can't tell the difference.

The very big issue to consider for my point of view, apart of some technical things as difference between PAL and NTSC types of HV20, is also the price you can buy it.

Consider that in US, you can buy HV20 at a equivalent cost of 650 Euro and in Japan also at less than 600 Euro, while in Europe you have to spend about a double price, so 1200 Euro.
Take chance to buy HV20 in US or Japan, during travel for business or vacation can be an interesting money saving.

What do you think to use a NTSC type in Europe, recording at 50 Hz AC network and playback to a multistandard HDTV ?

I agree with you. In fact, it's only noticeable if you switch between the original 25p and the slowed 24p, because of the audio tone shift (that could be fixed with a tonal correction filter).

That's what happen with all PAL DVD's, and even only a few have a tonal correction process, so... it's barely noticeable.

Good thing in Vegas they have automatic pitch correction :)

D.

Dang! You could buy a plane ticket, fly over here and get it and go home and still spend less than in Europe, why the high price?

Yooooooooooouuuuuuu'rrrrrrrrrreeeeeeeee rrrrrrrrrrriiiiiiiiiiigggggggggghhhhhttttttttt....Ddddddeeeennnnnnnnniiiiisssss.

Well, I guess it highly depends on where you're located. In Germany you can get it for 920 EUR (lowest price). I ordered mine in my country (Switzerland) for 1400 Swiss Francs (CHF)...thats 850 EUR or 1150 USD.

In Holland around the 850 and 950 euro. but the hv20 isn't still available:-(

I checked about the best price here in North Italy, now 950 Euro, PAL type of course.
Comparing to best price in Tokyo for NTSC, now less than 600 Euro, means
still a difference 350 Euro.

Wes,
I don't know reason of our Europe high price. May be it's only the 1,36 value between US Dollar and Euro ?
For me isn't a big problem to buy it in Tokyo without any plane ticket to buy, only doubts I have is to use an NTSC type with our PAL standard ( not for playback at least, I have a multistandard HDTV, but for some other tech. points like Toenis mentioned i.e. fluorescent flicker )
Have you some other tech. issues can convince me to spend 350 Euro more for a PAL type ?

The best thing of the PAL version is the 25p mode, wich works without any pulldown process.

Thanks guys. I think I will go with the PAL version. I've been read about the 24p pulldown hassle in another thread. A local main distributor of Canon products just called me this morning and told me HV20 is already here (in Indonesia) but I think the price is still too high, $1400. I'm going to wait a little while when it gets to retail stores. I know that PAL version is usually has higher price than NTSC but the price difference is just ridiculuos

Ian,
Do you mean 1400 Singapore dollars ?

I don't find 350 Euro is a ridicolous price difference between PAL and NTSC types.

Enrico, nope... that's in USD :) I checked BHPhotoVideo.com this morning, price is now dropped to $949.95 :)

Ian,

be careful, because B&H is in US so I think price 949.95 USD you checked is for NTSC type.