So I haven't bothered exporting my HD videos ( I use a XH-A1 & HV20 ) to SD DVD till now... I've burnt around 5 different DVD's with different settings using compressor and they all look really bad. I'm pretty confused about Field dominance settings ( actual project setting & setting in conversion in Compressor ) and if I should deinterlace in Compressor.

I'm a switcher as you can most likely tell, and at the same time of switching to Mac I went to HD...

So... What is your workflow to create a SD DVD from your HDV 1080i footage?

Paul /


Mpeg streamclip / Freeware for mac and pc will solve a lot of your
problems.

Search the forum on related Mpeg streamclip issues/ or downconvert
HDV to SD issues. Encoders differ in quality and results.

I,m on Pc following some of the fundamentals posted by Jason Livingstone.
Have a look at his posts too / It will clear the processes involved.

Herman.

I'm making the leap you're using Final Cut. I recommend editing in HDV, then export a Quicktime movie and uncheck the "make movie self contained" box to make it reference movie (much faster and little disk space). Take that movie into compressor and use the presets for best DVD for whatever length. Then use the files created in DVD Studio Pro. I've had terrific results. No need to deinterlace and field dominance for HDV is upper.

I don't know how Geoff got so lucky with his technique, but when I do exactly what he does I get jaggiez all over the place. The best way I've found is via the Bonzai Method (http://www3.telus.net/bonsai/Step-by-Step.html).

Another method I've tried that seems to work ok is by just letting DVDSP do the encoding instead of compressor, it looks a lot better.

Would HD DVD win already!!! Jeez, what a pain in the arse!

your footage is 60i? most everything i've taken to dvd has been 24p (pulldown removed), and it might be worth deinterlacing your footage prior to export. i've had some really good results capture/editing in HDV or AIC, and then exporting directly to compressor to the "best quality" dvd settings. there really isn't a need to export/render out to a full QT or even a ref mov when you can go straight from FCP to compressor

here's a dvd .img (will auto download when clicked) you can burn it or mount it and check it out in a normal dvd player.

http://file.meyersproduction.com/hv20/caddo/caddo%203min.img

I'm with Geoff, I get good results with the presets in Compressor. Make sure you're using the most recent version of FCP 5 and Compressor 2 (I'm assuming you haven't upgraded to FCS 2) as I think some earlier versions had problems with field order or the like.

I'm with Geoff, I get good results with the presets in Compressor. Make sure you're using the most recent version of FCP 5 and Compressor 2 (I'm assuming you haven't upgraded to FCS 2) as I think some earlier versions had problems with field order or the like.

Compressor 3 has not only much better user interface and extended functionality, but it seems doing the same jobs in much better quality (I would add: faster, too - although I dont have any comparison test results, just a feeling). I think it makes sense to upgrade to FCS2.

Other than that i follow the QT reference movie path - it works fine. I dont deinterlace, just drop the reference movie on compressor and let it do the job.