This movie was shot from the side of the road in my car.

I left the original soundtrack in the clip so you could all enjoy the moron that blew by me going at least 100mph.

I am very new to video camera work, so I am always open for suggestions.

Thanks!

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=A24W6G4P

This looks like it was shot at 1080i, 30fps. That's fine but I would take advantage of the uniqueness of the 24fps that the Canon offers. Try setting your cam on the 24fps setting. You have the perfect cam for nature shots like this and the deer footage is very "peaceful". Make sure you have the OIS set to on and be careful when zoomed in to keep the cam steady (one of the drawbacks of small, lightweight, cameras!). Very nice and thanks for sharing your footage!

Thanks for your feedback.

I am not sure if I like the 24p feature yet or not.

The picture looks jerky to me when panning. Is this normal?

That's been my experience with it so far, but I haven't played with it all that much. I'm a complete novice too, so I certainly don't know all of the tricks that could be employed to make it look better.

Steve

The American Cinematographer's Manual and cinematographers for years have guidelines set forth for panning speeds at 24p. You'd be surprised how slow one needs to pan according to those charts! Yes, the "judder" is quite normal and when properly controlled yields that dreamy movie "look".

Nice footage. I think 24P vs 60i will be debated forever, much like 1080i vs 720p is with HD broadcasts now.

I've shot a little of both with my HV20 and I prefer the 24P although I'm sure there are situations where I would go 60i. The deal breaker for me is the better low light performance of 24P. If you keep in mind the limitations of 24P (smooth camera movement) - or just plan to edit the heck out of your video anyway - that is my preference. But the quality is really staggering either way with this little monster.

Hi Jacob,
can you please shoot again something in 24p Mode and upload again to
megaupload.com ?
Many thanks in advance.

Regards, Stefan.

I'd almost like to see someone setup two identical cameras next to one another and record the same scene in 30p and 24p to see what the difference really is.

sadly the hv20 doesnt shoot 30p

Correct, the HV20 does not do 30p. :(

As requested, here is the same scene shot twice. Once in 24p, and once in 60i.

Here is the link for the 60i clip:

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=64D3S0LC

Here is the link shot in 24p: I removed the pulldown in this clip with Cineform trial version.

http://www.megaupload.com/?d=KNE8UMG8

To me, the 60i clip pans so much smoother and is easier for a newbie like me to shoot.

Does the 24p clip look normal to you? I mean, is it supposed to jump around like that?

I just realized something. I wonder if my computer is not showing the video correctly.

I do not own a HDTV yet, so I can only play back the movies on my 22" widescreen PC monitor.

Is it possible that my computer screen would display 24p differently then 60i?

Jacob, I tested now the 24 p Version.
Plays very smooth on my P4 laptop
with 1400x1050 screen size, if I use the virtual 1920x1080x32 Bit
mode with my ATI driver and in fullscreen mode with Mediaplayer Classic.

It has got nice motion blurr, so the panning is not very shaky !

But compared to the Baseball 24p clip Chris posted in the other thread, you can see there, that the pulldown into 60i makes the 24p clips very shaky !

So one really must remove the pulldown to get a good playing movie !

I wonder, if the HV20 is a bit unsharper than the HV10 ?
I have seen much sharper detailed HV10 clips already and the HV20
seems a bit more blurry all in all ?
Could this be ? or is it just an imperfection of the autofocus mode ?

Many thanks.

Regards, Stefan.
P.S:Am currently downloading the 60i version and will compare it later.

Hmm,
now the 60i Version is still much more shaky than the 24 p
version on my Laptop, also with a 3.2 Ghz Pentium 4 !

Maybe Mediaplayer Classic can not handle so fast panning
with this MPEG-2 codec ?

This camera is just about good enough to make me ok giving up a manual focus ring...but not quite...I'll hold out for my HD100ish...dang it!

I'd love to play with one though to see how I could push it...$1k is a great price point for footage that pretty!

Stefan, the 24p clip looks smoother then the 60i clip for you?

I am really starting to think it is my PC then.

I am running a P4 3.0 Ghz with 1.5GB of RAM. I also have a Nvidia Geforce 7800GT with purevideo encoder.

This video card handles all of the decoding on HDV vids, so I know it is not that my CPU is bottoming out.

The funny thing is, when I watch the 24p clips, it almost looks like it is interlaced and I have the fields backwards. I do not see any interlaced lines, but it jumps around like an interlaced clip with the fields in reverse.

If I import the clip into VirtualDub, each frame looks correct until I play it.

Jacob, if this wasn't shot in the HDV24 setting to begin with, Cineform has no pulldown to remove and is probably removing good fields/frames. When I brought this in to VirtualDub the first day you posted it, I could clearly tell it was shot in 60i HDV so there is no pulldown to begin with, just interlaced artifacts. The pulldown is only put in there with the HDV24 setting in the camera, no other way is it put in. Try just simply deinterlacing it with a quality "area/motion" based deinterlacer to convert it to 30p or better yet, Magic Bullet suite to covert the 60i footage to a faux 24p). I recommend Virtualdub because it also has a good Deshaker plug-in that has been a lifesaver for me in the past. Give it a try.

Jacob, if this wasn't shot in the HDV24 setting to begin with, Cineform has no pulldown to remove and is probably removing good fields/frames. When I brought this in to VirtualDub the first day you posted it, I could clearly tell it was shot in 60i HDV so there is no pulldown to begin with, just interlaced artifacts. The pulldown is only put in there with the HDV24 setting in the camera, no other way is it put in. Try just simply deinterlacing it with a quality "area/motion" based deinterlacer to convert it to 30p or better yet, Magic Bullet suite to covert the 60i footage to a faux 24p). I recommend Virtualdub because it also has a good Deshaker plug-in that has been a lifesaver for me in the past. Give it a try.

You are correct. The first clip I posted was shot in 60i. I was talking about the two other clips I posted later in this thread. One of them was shot in 24p.

Thanks for the tip on magic bullet. I am going to check it out.