If you need only ocasionaly a LANC zoom/rec controller for the A1 I want to signal the Libec ZC-3DV that I bought from B&H. It works great with the A1 and it has also a mode for the Panasonic. A great little product for just $109. I guess the entry level products of other brands can't do much more than this at twice the price:
http://tinyurl.com/ya6kro


Regards
Gabriele

That is not to shabby.

There's a whole thread on this LANC:
http://dvinfo.net/conf/showthread.php?t=43345

IMO the Zoe is a quantum leap better at twice the price with zoom limiters and one-touch autofocus. It's about as good as you'll get with a LANC.

I have no idea why anyone with a decent camera would buy a $20 polarizer in a plastic bag.... or try panning with a $200 tripod.... or recycle $4 tapes.... or buy off-brand batteries... etc etc...

There's a whole thread on this LANC:
http://dvinfo.net/conf/showthread.php?t=43345
I have no idea why anyone with a decent camera would buy a $20 polarizer in a plastic bag.... or try panning with a $200 tripod.... or recycle $4 tapes.... or buy off-brand batteries... etc etc...
It really depend what you use it for. Agree on the polarizer but for a LANC controller if you use it twice a year why not. This controller is really good actually. BTE when I had the GL1 I bought off-brand batteries they were better than the original Canon. I'm sure mileage varies, the new graphite canon are very good but for many products off-brand doesn't always mean bad products.
Libec BTW is not Manfrotto but is a pretty well known brand.

Agreed, as long as it works for the job, without significant comprimises, there is no reason not to purchase it.

I like to have nice gear, but I don't always buy the best most expensive products, otherwise I wouldn't have settled for the A1.

I understand that you usually get what you pay for, and yet you get a pretty functional LANC controller for $110.

a LANC controller... if you use it twice a year why not. Twice a year? That's all you ever shoot from a tripod? I'm still trying to figure out the best way to permanently attach a LANC controller to a pan handle. I'll never shoot from a tripod without one.

I bought a Libec 22 tripod from Zotz, and the lanc controller came for free as a special promo that's going on now.

A LANC is absolutely essential - I just wish they made one fully optimized with direct control of all essential camera functions PLUS a simple shotbox for presets. Drilling down through menus on LCD's really shouldn't be necessary during any shoot. WB/OIS/AF/Gain etc...

Ken Tanaka did a very comprehensive review of the Zoe here: http://www.dvinfo.net/articles/camaccs/zoedvlanc.php

The new model has silent raised buttons instead of the clickers and a lower price ~235-ish. Well engineered, with a full-range of features and the best zoom control of any sub-$1000 controller.

The Canon ZR-2000 is as close as it comes for functionality. It's cheap and plastic (too big negatives in my opinion) but it includes focus assist and AE shift. And discrete zoom speeds just like the hand grip (Z1 through Z16).

Now if only it had a menu access wheel scroller and the CP select and trigger buttons, that would be ideal. As long as I'm dreaming, it would also be great if it had the focus & zoom position select and trigger buttons too.

Twice a year? That's all you ever shoot from a tripod? I'm still trying to figure out the best way to permanently attach a LANC controller to a pan handle. I'll never shoot from a tripod without one.
Hehe, I was exagerating to make a point but I'm not a pro. I don't use the tripod too much since I mostly use the camera during my travels. I was thinking today though that I can use the controller on my glidecam. I use the glidecam more than the tripod although even that one with moderation since everybody look at you when you have that thing. Also I found out that in terms of anti-vibration the A1 is really exceptional. Much better than all the other cameras I ever got. I may do handholding even more...

Moved from Canon XH forum to Remote Lens Controllers.

I just got the Zoe DVXL controller - can highly recommend it. The sensitivity of the rocker and button location makes it a "natural shooter." As good as the high-end betacams I used to use.
I was very disappointed with the Sony a1u's zoom, but this unit makes it into a good zoom. Too bad it ate up half of the camcorder rebate.

Features:
Record
Power
Zoom
Manual focus
two-click - snap focus (works great)
Works on Sony/Pana/Canon.

Are you using this with an XH-A1? If so, are all the focus functions operational? ie manual vs auto and one push focus. Good info is hard to find!

Jay,

I am using the Zoe DVXL with the A1. The focus controls are dependant on the focus mode switch on the camera. Basically, you can't switch auto/manual from the Zoe. But if you're in manual, you can select focus on the Zoe and focus with the rocker. I haven't found a need for this yet so for me it amounts to money spent that I'm not benefiting from. Bottom line, Zoe on A1, nice rocker, selectable max zoom speed, start stop record. That's about it.

Thanks Wade - Looks like the Zoe wins for the precise zoom / focus controls (133 degree stepless rotation) essential on a tripod. The '2-click' snap focus that James listed above is a bonus. Zoe (bebob.de) mentions a 'long-push' for instant focus. May be same thing, done differently?

Once I get a few non-video projects out of the way I may try the maligned Canon 2000 with the intent of repackaging it into a hunk of CNC'd aluminum. It really does look like a $19.95 remote.

Jay,

Looks like James is using it on a Sony A1U. I'm not sure the "snap focus" responds the same on the A1. I'll try and test it out in the next few days and let you know.

Awaiting UPS for a DVXL... even with the A1 locked down and sandbagged on a 'real' tripod, just looking at the zoom controls causes frame movement. It's obvious that decent HD field work requires more than a casual investment in accessory items but the results are priceless.