Lars Siden
May 28th, 2006, 01:18 PM
Having too much sparetime(....) - I decided to do a shoot out comparing mpeg2 encoders. Borrowed some time from my friends to run my test.avi on their software and using some trials I ended up with this:
Testfile: 10 seconds colorbars(PAL) with scrolling creditroll (multicolored), size: 37mb(no audio)
CinemaCraft SP Trial:
Size: 7.3mb
Template: PAL DVD
Speed: Excellent, 3.6x realtime
Quality: Soft - nice looking, some problems with the borders between colors. Overall good looking
ProCoder2:
Size: 7.3mb
Template: PAL DVD(HQ)
Speed: Good, 1.3x realtime
Quality: Crisp, nice looking. Some colorproblems with purple and black
Sorensson Squeeze:
Size: 4.4mb
Template: DVD PAL High
Speed: Good, 1.7x realtime
Quality: Very good. Dark grey bar vanished in testpicture - probably some automatic filter going on.
Sony Vegas MC, standard and "High"(2 pass)
Size: 3.4mb(standard), 3.5mb(High)
Template: DVD PAL and DVD PAL Video High Q
Speed: fair, 0.9x realtime
Quality: Surpricingly good! All colors are correct, no jitters in the borders between colors.
Conclusion:
Average quality, high speed, big file = go for cinema craft( Basic is just 58 USD )
Good quality, good speed = go for Procoder2 express( 50-60 USD ), big file
High Quality, slow speed = MainConcept, small file
Comments?
// Lazze
Testfile: 10 seconds colorbars(PAL) with scrolling creditroll (multicolored), size: 37mb(no audio)
CinemaCraft SP Trial:
Size: 7.3mb
Template: PAL DVD
Speed: Excellent, 3.6x realtime
Quality: Soft - nice looking, some problems with the borders between colors. Overall good looking
ProCoder2:
Size: 7.3mb
Template: PAL DVD(HQ)
Speed: Good, 1.3x realtime
Quality: Crisp, nice looking. Some colorproblems with purple and black
Sorensson Squeeze:
Size: 4.4mb
Template: DVD PAL High
Speed: Good, 1.7x realtime
Quality: Very good. Dark grey bar vanished in testpicture - probably some automatic filter going on.
Sony Vegas MC, standard and "High"(2 pass)
Size: 3.4mb(standard), 3.5mb(High)
Template: DVD PAL and DVD PAL Video High Q
Speed: fair, 0.9x realtime
Quality: Surpricingly good! All colors are correct, no jitters in the borders between colors.
Conclusion:
Average quality, high speed, big file = go for cinema craft( Basic is just 58 USD )
Good quality, good speed = go for Procoder2 express( 50-60 USD ), big file
High Quality, slow speed = MainConcept, small file
Comments?
// Lazze