Lee Mullen
November 3rd, 2012, 01:31 AM
After watching this video Canon 3x XL Wide Angle Video Lens - YouTube
It made me wonder why no EOS/EF lens has any built in ND filter. Any readon for this or do some models have it, seems odd considering XL lenses had them?
Caleb Reynolds
November 3rd, 2012, 06:25 AM
I would rather stack them on the front of the lens so I can "fine tune" how much ND i use. Plus it helps me adapt to different lighting situations when I am using practicals (light from sources already there)
Ronald Jackson
November 3rd, 2012, 11:18 AM
You cannot stop down Canon XL video lenses below about F11, this may go for other makes of video cam.
Something to do with the cameras being at their optimum a stop of two or three away from maximum aperture. Thus built in ND filters.
I'd love a built in filter (three settings on my XLH1) on my EF lenses as a real pain having to screw/unscrew filters from the front, as today, in variable lighting conditions. A simple switch on the video lenses.
Judging by their prices, video lenses, broadcast ones, are a lot more technologically advanced than still ones.
Ron
Phil Murray
November 3rd, 2012, 08:13 PM
I, too, would love to have that feature. I'm sure there is a reason because they would certainly be helpful when using a DSLR. I'm the middle of the Peruvian Amazon right now and have variable ND filters for two of my lenses. They have, of course, made a huge difference in many situations. This trip came up at the last minute and I decided the day before that I would my 60D. It was a good choice, but in rushing to pack, I forgot the vari-ND filter for the only IS, walkabout lens that I brought. I can't tell you how many times I really needed it. Had to shoot at a very high shutter speed too much and don't expect the results to be very useful. (Fortunately, this is a quick scouting trip for a more lengthy shot sometime in the next 6-8 months.)
I find I worry about filters a lot less with video so I can shot flat keep a more consistent color across all shots for easier grading in post. Having the ND filter -- a MUST -- on the lens is so very convenient on my EX1r.