Dan Dubowitz
March 26th, 2011, 05:07 AM
What is the difference in viewing image quality between a screen sold as a monitor and one sold as an HD television?
I am a visual artist making an artwork, a triptych that comprises 3 synchronous films viewed side by side (viewed and screened portrait format) on 3 screens, it will be viewed in galleries. I propose to strip the casing off three tv's or monitors and build them into a unified case. (I need the screens to be closer together than they are with their original housing on). I will output the three 3 films to the 3 screens from 3 blu ray players with hdmi leads.
The 3 films have been shot in hd on a canon 5d, and will shortly be edited on FCP and burnt to blu ray. I have a budget to buy 3 screens at aprox $600 per screen. I am looking in the range of 24-37inch, assuming that the image wont be as sharp if i go any bigger than 37inch.
I live in the middle of nowhere, so i cant just walk into a shop and try and see the difference, I need to order something blind (probably in the uk with amazon).
My first question is whether i will find a better screen from an hd tv, such as a sony bravia or samsung, or whether i will get a better image from the monitor range, such as the samsung synchmaster. I assume i can drive either from a bluray and hdmi lead. My second question is whether i will gain any benefit in image quality from on the screen if i go for an led back lit screen. My third question is, am i mad to go larger than 24 inches, seeing as prople can walk right up to the installation, or am i safe upto 37 inches? My fourth question is if anyone can recommend which direction to go on chosing what to buy. I am aware that it can be pot luck as to what lcd is actually in the units, i have some positive experience with samsung and sony, less so with lg. none with panasonic. the only good screen i have used todat is an eizo, but this is out of budget range!
the film itself is of the moving shaddows from dance performed inside underlit napoleonic stone towers, the images are slow shutter speed, incredibly noisy, and with a large area of the image close to black.
I have made something along these lines before with 12 screens, image below, the challenges werent the same, as the audience viewing distance was set back at 3 metres. This time i will need to take account of the viewing angles, and on the horizontal axis, not vertical.
any thoughts on this would be warmly appreciated
many thanks
Dan Dubowitz
this is the first project in the series for an idea of how its to be set up
Installation photographs | Dan Dubowitz / Civic Works (http://www.civicworks.net/02-tattered-outlaws-of-history/02-installation-photographs/)
I am a visual artist making an artwork, a triptych that comprises 3 synchronous films viewed side by side (viewed and screened portrait format) on 3 screens, it will be viewed in galleries. I propose to strip the casing off three tv's or monitors and build them into a unified case. (I need the screens to be closer together than they are with their original housing on). I will output the three 3 films to the 3 screens from 3 blu ray players with hdmi leads.
The 3 films have been shot in hd on a canon 5d, and will shortly be edited on FCP and burnt to blu ray. I have a budget to buy 3 screens at aprox $600 per screen. I am looking in the range of 24-37inch, assuming that the image wont be as sharp if i go any bigger than 37inch.
I live in the middle of nowhere, so i cant just walk into a shop and try and see the difference, I need to order something blind (probably in the uk with amazon).
My first question is whether i will find a better screen from an hd tv, such as a sony bravia or samsung, or whether i will get a better image from the monitor range, such as the samsung synchmaster. I assume i can drive either from a bluray and hdmi lead. My second question is whether i will gain any benefit in image quality from on the screen if i go for an led back lit screen. My third question is, am i mad to go larger than 24 inches, seeing as prople can walk right up to the installation, or am i safe upto 37 inches? My fourth question is if anyone can recommend which direction to go on chosing what to buy. I am aware that it can be pot luck as to what lcd is actually in the units, i have some positive experience with samsung and sony, less so with lg. none with panasonic. the only good screen i have used todat is an eizo, but this is out of budget range!
the film itself is of the moving shaddows from dance performed inside underlit napoleonic stone towers, the images are slow shutter speed, incredibly noisy, and with a large area of the image close to black.
I have made something along these lines before with 12 screens, image below, the challenges werent the same, as the audience viewing distance was set back at 3 metres. This time i will need to take account of the viewing angles, and on the horizontal axis, not vertical.
any thoughts on this would be warmly appreciated
many thanks
Dan Dubowitz
this is the first project in the series for an idea of how its to be set up
Installation photographs | Dan Dubowitz / Civic Works (http://www.civicworks.net/02-tattered-outlaws-of-history/02-installation-photographs/)