I have heard that the ef adapter is not compatable with the XL Hia and s camcorders. Does anyone out there know, for sure, if this is true? Is anyone using it successfully? Thanks folks.

Gene...

Good evening,

The ef adapter works just fine on the xlh1.

Hi Eugene,

Not sure about all the differences between the XL-H1 and the XL-H1A, but the adapter does work with the XL-H1A. I haven't used it much, but did some experimentation to determine its capabilities. I could not take still photos with it. Whenever I tried, I got a message in the viewfinder, "THIS LENS HAS NO STILL SHOOTING CAPABILITY". Auto focus does not work either, but Image Stabilization works normally. The adapter takes a 2CR5 battery. Two were included. It powers up when the camera is powered on and in a recording mode. It does not power up in VCR mode or without a lens attached to it.
The Canon web-site has a big list of compatible lenses. It lists the 10-22mm EF-S lens. I happen to have this lens and it cannot be fitted to the adapter. I tried out my three L series lenses (70-200, 100-400, 24-105) and they all worked fine. Tried a Sigma 50mm 1:2.8 DG Macro lens also, and it produced a good image.
The warning "HD INCOMPATIBLE LENS" appears momentarily if you power up in an HD mode or switch from SD to HD mode; however, all of the HD/SD/frame rate selections recorded as normal, just like with the stock lens. The HD was captured to Vegas Pro 8 as .m2t files, so I'm not sure why the warning appears, other than that the lenses aren't rated as HD. Bottom line, not using HD lenses doesn't prevent you from recording in HD mode.
Per the Canon web-site, "This allows users to attach Canon EF lenses to the XL-H1. The difference in size between the XL-H1's 1/3-inch CCD's and 35mm film means that the effective focal length of still camera lenses is multiplied by 8.8x (4:3)/7.2x(16:9)." I did not test the 4:3 format.
Using a dSLR (Canon 50D) with a 1.6 crop factor sensor, and a 400mm lens, I took a shot of a wall that was 260 feet away from me. The scene recorded about 15 feet of the wall's width. The same lens attached to the XL-H1A with the adaper, provided a scene width that was 4 feet wide from a distance of 260 feet.
The camera doesn't need to be removed from the tripod to install/remove the adapter.
The 1.4x Extender also works with this adapter.

Multi-lingual manual....

Thank you Dale and Mark. I am considering purchasing this camera and needed to know to help me decide betweeen the XL and XH series.

Gene...

One last thing: On the XL H1a and S the iris adjustment is now on the lense. When the adapter is attached how are you manually adjusting the iris? Thanks.

Gene...

Eugene,

The iris can also be controlled by a small dial at the forward, left-hand side of the camera.

Great, thanks again. You have been of immense help.

Gene...

Good evening,


Just a few thoughts:

If you are going to go to bigger telephoto and zoom lenses you will need a rail of some sort to support the lens!!!

I used a cavivision rod support first and that just did not work in helping steady the camera.

the biggest issue is the weight on your ef adaptor.

You can make a wooden support if all you will be using is a single lens like a 100 to 400 zoom. it is cheap, light and it works. However if you will be changing lenses then you will need to find a used ron's rail or such. sadly he does not make them any more.

[I] got so frustrated with this I broke down and had a machinest in Belgium build me a rail.

With the bigger lenses you should get a 1x sight, mount it on your hot shoe and it will get you on tag=rget every time. I bouhgt mine at wall mart for 40 bucks. and got a shoe adapter for it.

Photosolve Home > Products > Xtend-a-Sight (http://www.photosolve.com/main/product/xtendasight/index.html)

this man made my rail, it was not cheap but it is excellent.

Andree Gothe <andree@mail.dk>


Oh yea, The lens foot and the tripod mount on the camera are not in line with each other. If you go to acquire a rail of some sort or build one, remember you need lateral movement on the front end!!!

Dale Guthormsen

Ronsrail in USA was a good (if expensive) support system for super telephoto Canon and Nikon lenses on the XL camcorders, but sadly he no longer makes them.

For those of you in UK who aren't prepared to make their own heavy duty support, the engineering workshop at True Lens Services will build you any lens & tripod support to fit your requirements:

True Lens Services (http://www.truelens.co.uk/)