Dylan Pank
November 3rd, 2004, 06:10 PM
Hi there.
I'm, new around these partsd so go easy on me.
I've been messing around with Kako Itu's excellent footage. But am having a few problems getting my evil way with it. I'm just throwing in these ideas for the benefit of discussion and have no problem with anyone just responding by saying :"WHAT! ARE YOU CRAZY? WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU'RE DOING?"
1. FFmpegX. I wanted to demultiplex the files into mp2 and .m2v files. FFmpegX's demultiplexer woun't accept anythng but .vob or .mpg files, and no, changing the file suffix doesn't work. I also tried using ffmpeg to transcribe into DV. This was a little more successful but still hit and miss. some files (cocoon) seemed to work great, but others either took on strange frame rates (QT always insisted they were 29.97 but it looked faster to me) or failed completely. Some were OK. However on a few the sound stuttered and repeated. Still it showed some promise.
2 DiVA - a bit more reliable than FFmpegX. Again it could be transcoded to DV or any other format but again weird things started to happen. If I deinterlaced (essential in all cases as neither FFmpegX nor DiVA can do field by field rescaling, only on the frame as a whole) then the resulting frame rate seems to be 23.976 in some cases. Even when this didn't seem to be the case there were problems - when I tried to paste the DiVA converted DV cocoon footage (whch QT claimed was 29.97) over the audio from the FFmpegX DV converted cocoon footage, it was out of sync.
DiVA also cannot transcode audio.
3. mpegtxwrap - I wanted to use this to demultiplex but had no luck. others have mention this on the forum but I had no joy with it. It spat out a few sub 4Mb files and then gave up. I'm using panther - what could I be doing wrong? Do I have to give up and buy LumiereHD? Actually it's very reasonably priced (compared to other solutions), but I'm a total skinflint.
I'm shooting to shoot a short film in the new year and am hoping I might be able to rent a 50i model here in the UK and use the short film as a test for the format. I have a feature length project that I am planning to shoot in the summer. AT the moment my set up is limited to a pretty ancient (don't ask how ancient) G4 and Premiere 6.5 but I'm an academic (hence the unwillingness to spend anything), so I have plenty of spare time at weekends and evenings, and busy days teaching when I can leave the machine churning out renders.
Thoughts? Inputs?Gasps of Horror?
I'm, new around these partsd so go easy on me.
I've been messing around with Kako Itu's excellent footage. But am having a few problems getting my evil way with it. I'm just throwing in these ideas for the benefit of discussion and have no problem with anyone just responding by saying :"WHAT! ARE YOU CRAZY? WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU'RE DOING?"
1. FFmpegX. I wanted to demultiplex the files into mp2 and .m2v files. FFmpegX's demultiplexer woun't accept anythng but .vob or .mpg files, and no, changing the file suffix doesn't work. I also tried using ffmpeg to transcribe into DV. This was a little more successful but still hit and miss. some files (cocoon) seemed to work great, but others either took on strange frame rates (QT always insisted they were 29.97 but it looked faster to me) or failed completely. Some were OK. However on a few the sound stuttered and repeated. Still it showed some promise.
2 DiVA - a bit more reliable than FFmpegX. Again it could be transcoded to DV or any other format but again weird things started to happen. If I deinterlaced (essential in all cases as neither FFmpegX nor DiVA can do field by field rescaling, only on the frame as a whole) then the resulting frame rate seems to be 23.976 in some cases. Even when this didn't seem to be the case there were problems - when I tried to paste the DiVA converted DV cocoon footage (whch QT claimed was 29.97) over the audio from the FFmpegX DV converted cocoon footage, it was out of sync.
DiVA also cannot transcode audio.
3. mpegtxwrap - I wanted to use this to demultiplex but had no luck. others have mention this on the forum but I had no joy with it. It spat out a few sub 4Mb files and then gave up. I'm using panther - what could I be doing wrong? Do I have to give up and buy LumiereHD? Actually it's very reasonably priced (compared to other solutions), but I'm a total skinflint.
I'm shooting to shoot a short film in the new year and am hoping I might be able to rent a 50i model here in the UK and use the short film as a test for the format. I have a feature length project that I am planning to shoot in the summer. AT the moment my set up is limited to a pretty ancient (don't ask how ancient) G4 and Premiere 6.5 but I'm an academic (hence the unwillingness to spend anything), so I have plenty of spare time at weekends and evenings, and busy days teaching when I can leave the machine churning out renders.
Thoughts? Inputs?Gasps of Horror?