Ken Hodson
September 11th, 2004, 01:55 AM
With the advertising punch Sony has just pulled( huge considering we have been in the HDV world a while now) one has to wonder if Sony has just made %80 of their products obsolete?
How many of their current prosummer DV cams cams do they hope to sell given the price and apparent capabilities of the new cam? Does it have any DV/SD modes at all? I haven't read a thing.
How much does Sony want to wipe out their $8,000 to $20,000 cam range product line-up? If we believe the marketing this cam has everything (minus XLR and detachable lens and esspecially progressive scan, which they will try to convince you isn't important) else is sub-par.
I am less inclined to give credabilty to the "leaked" visuals, as we can not give the sources any credability or put them in any context. I for one believe the output from this cam to be far from miraculous given the price tag set by Sony. I bet it is good, as so far the HDV format has been, but something tells me Sony has held back in some respect as they have too many product lines to step on. We will only know for sure when the cam is on our hands. Going by Sony's specs it blows everything else under $15,000 out of the water. Interesting.
My personal opinion is, that to not offer progressive capture in any mode is a joke. Interlace for distribution is fine as it cuts down on the data rate, but interlace capture is inherently crap. If you like the look of video it's fine. If you like the look of film you have to de-interlace. Say good-by to 1/4 of your resolution minimum and welcome de-interlace artifacts. Considering this cam doesn't come close to the true 1080i resolution in pixels captured, where does this leave us? And if you are a modern media artist who relies upon compositing, who wants to de-interlace? For the life of me I can't understand why they didn't include a 720 30p mode. Why? Is it all a conspiracy. No manual controlls in one, no progressive in another?
I can't wait for a legit review. Hopefully non Sony sponsored if that is possible. Should be around March, shortly after this cam shops in volume.
One thing for sure, I would bite the ass off a dead horse to have those manual controls on my HD-10 ;>)
Long live the HD-10 and welcome the FX1 !
HDV is here to stay.
How many of their current prosummer DV cams cams do they hope to sell given the price and apparent capabilities of the new cam? Does it have any DV/SD modes at all? I haven't read a thing.
How much does Sony want to wipe out their $8,000 to $20,000 cam range product line-up? If we believe the marketing this cam has everything (minus XLR and detachable lens and esspecially progressive scan, which they will try to convince you isn't important) else is sub-par.
I am less inclined to give credabilty to the "leaked" visuals, as we can not give the sources any credability or put them in any context. I for one believe the output from this cam to be far from miraculous given the price tag set by Sony. I bet it is good, as so far the HDV format has been, but something tells me Sony has held back in some respect as they have too many product lines to step on. We will only know for sure when the cam is on our hands. Going by Sony's specs it blows everything else under $15,000 out of the water. Interesting.
My personal opinion is, that to not offer progressive capture in any mode is a joke. Interlace for distribution is fine as it cuts down on the data rate, but interlace capture is inherently crap. If you like the look of video it's fine. If you like the look of film you have to de-interlace. Say good-by to 1/4 of your resolution minimum and welcome de-interlace artifacts. Considering this cam doesn't come close to the true 1080i resolution in pixels captured, where does this leave us? And if you are a modern media artist who relies upon compositing, who wants to de-interlace? For the life of me I can't understand why they didn't include a 720 30p mode. Why? Is it all a conspiracy. No manual controlls in one, no progressive in another?
I can't wait for a legit review. Hopefully non Sony sponsored if that is possible. Should be around March, shortly after this cam shops in volume.
One thing for sure, I would bite the ass off a dead horse to have those manual controls on my HD-10 ;>)
Long live the HD-10 and welcome the FX1 !
HDV is here to stay.