Guy McLoughlin
February 26th, 2009, 10:47 AM
...After two years of shooting corporate/medical videos with a Canon HV20,
I switched to the HG21, and could not be happier!
MAJOR DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE HV20 AND HG21
- HG21 is almost silent. On camera mics have always been a problem with the HV20
because of the noisy tape transport.
- HG21 LCD display has a much wider viewing angle, making it much easier to judge
manual exposure when your view is not dead-on to the display.
- HG21 power-saving stand-by mode is very handy. Just close the LCD display and
the camera goes in to stand-by mode, which can be set to last up to 30 minutes.
To start shooting again, just open the LCD display and you are ready to go.
- I've grown to like having the push-button/joy-stick control on the LCD monitor,
because I can adjust the camera when I am standing in front of it, which was not
possible with the HV20.
- I am getting much better low-light color accuracy and low-noise with the HG21
compared to the HV20. I switch to 1/30 sec TV mode with the frame rate set to
30P, then manually adjust the gain to get a good exposure.
- Using a BeachTek DXA-2S XLR adapter, I am getting much better audio from the
HG21 than I ever got from the HV20. Better dynamic range, much quieter noise
levels from LINE feeds or directly from my SoundDevices MixPre mixer.
- About the only drawback to the HG21 is the cost of the BP-827 batteries, which
run about $120 at B&H Photo, and last about 4.5 hours when recording. I bought
three batteries and two CG-800 wall chargers, so I can shoot all day without having
to worry about power.
*** Update ***
At the HV20 website, someone posted a link at BestBatt.com for generic BP-827
batteries for $67. I bought 3 Best Batt batteries for my HV20 and have been totally
happy with them, so I would expect these batteries to be just as good.
http://www.bestbatt.com/Canon_BP_827_BP827_Camcorder_Battery_p/bbbp827.htm
I switched to the HG21, and could not be happier!
MAJOR DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE HV20 AND HG21
- HG21 is almost silent. On camera mics have always been a problem with the HV20
because of the noisy tape transport.
- HG21 LCD display has a much wider viewing angle, making it much easier to judge
manual exposure when your view is not dead-on to the display.
- HG21 power-saving stand-by mode is very handy. Just close the LCD display and
the camera goes in to stand-by mode, which can be set to last up to 30 minutes.
To start shooting again, just open the LCD display and you are ready to go.
- I've grown to like having the push-button/joy-stick control on the LCD monitor,
because I can adjust the camera when I am standing in front of it, which was not
possible with the HV20.
- I am getting much better low-light color accuracy and low-noise with the HG21
compared to the HV20. I switch to 1/30 sec TV mode with the frame rate set to
30P, then manually adjust the gain to get a good exposure.
- Using a BeachTek DXA-2S XLR adapter, I am getting much better audio from the
HG21 than I ever got from the HV20. Better dynamic range, much quieter noise
levels from LINE feeds or directly from my SoundDevices MixPre mixer.
- About the only drawback to the HG21 is the cost of the BP-827 batteries, which
run about $120 at B&H Photo, and last about 4.5 hours when recording. I bought
three batteries and two CG-800 wall chargers, so I can shoot all day without having
to worry about power.
*** Update ***
At the HV20 website, someone posted a link at BestBatt.com for generic BP-827
batteries for $67. I bought 3 Best Batt batteries for my HV20 and have been totally
happy with them, so I would expect these batteries to be just as good.
http://www.bestbatt.com/Canon_BP_827_BP827_Camcorder_Battery_p/bbbp827.htm