View Full Version : Dreaded white DOT
Wayne Avanson April 4th, 2008, 03:37 PM Hi Everyone.
A little problem keeps re appearing (occasionally) and I wondered if anyone else had had the same. On some shoots, I get a little white dot, right and high of centre which is like a dead pixel kind of efect. It only happens sometimes, and unfortunately always seems to be when shooting for clients and the camera is on a long time and it's got all warm to the touch. I was wondering if this heat has something to do with it as I can't think of another reason. It has happened both on battery and mains operation.
I'm taking it back to the shop this week for them to have a look, and if they can't figure it out, it's off to JVC for a repair, but obviously I'd love to avoid the hassle.
Apart from that I love this camera, it's ace.
Cheers in advance.
Wayne
PS Cheers for the great book Steve, it's been of enormous help.
David Benjamin April 21st, 2008, 11:34 PM This happened to me too. I've had my camera since December and have never noticed it before, but it happened to some (not all) of the footage I filmed yesterday. The position and coloring of the pixel is exactly as you described it. My first thought was that the humidity of the shooting conditions played a role, as I was filming in a bathroom with the shower water running. Later, when I played back the footage on a TV and noticed the pixel, I filmed a few seconds to test it out--and that time the white pixel didn't appear.
Camera warmth is a factor I hadn't considered. I'm going to check my other footage to see if that might have been a cause before. Otherwise the only variable I can think of is the moisture.
So what did the shop determine, Wayne? Did you end up sending it back to JVC?
Wayne Avanson April 22nd, 2008, 12:27 AM Hi Benjamin
I haven't had time to take it back yet and I have been using the camera for client's work so I'm afraid if it has to go back to JVC I'll be stuffed. I have two jobs coming up and then after that I might take it down and see. Since I got the camera in October, it has happened three times. all three occasions were warm conditions, only two were prolonged shooting where the camera got really quite hot.
Thanks for letting me know and if there's any news, I'll post it.
Interesting that you got yours in December and I got mine in October. Conceivably a 'bad batch'?
Wayne
Steve Mullen April 22nd, 2008, 05:21 AM Hopefully -- it's only heat.
Also try a System reset!
Greg Huber April 23rd, 2008, 06:58 PM I've had my GZHD7 since December of 2007. I've been using it a quite a bit and am very happy with it.
I just got done recording a wedding last week and I noticed about 4 bright white pixels in the bottom center-left part of the screen. I went back to look at some older footage (from December year) and the pixels were there also. Funny I didn't really notice it until now. However, similar to what the OP is saying, it is not consistent. Some footage has the white pixels, others do not. It seems like the more video I record the more likely it is there.
Fortunately I got a 4 year extended warranty when I purchased the camera. I tried e-mailing the JVC site but found out they only cover 3 months labor and 12 months parts. They haven't replied back yet. I may try the system reset to see if it makes a difference.
Wayne Avanson April 25th, 2008, 04:22 PM I've done the system preset and am waiting to see if the white dot appears again. Since it is an intermittent fault I'll just have to wait.
Hopefully, it won't be when I'm using it for a real paid job like last time!!!!
In fact, hopefully, it won't be AT ALL!
I might get the camera hot and run it for a couple of hours to see if it turns up again. I'll try it sometime soon.
Anyone else have problems like this, feel free to let us know here
Wayne
David Benjamin April 27th, 2008, 11:45 AM I too just did the system preset, and will pay attention to see if it recurs. In the worst case scenario, however, I figured out a way to remove the dot in Final Cut Pro. (I just duplicated the video field and cropped the upper one to just around the white dot. The way that FCP composites the fields blended it mostly out of existence so it's only barely noticeable when on a solid black background.)
Wayne Avanson April 27th, 2008, 12:07 PM Sounds like a winner as a last resort I think.
I have some shoots to do in the next couple of weeks so I'll be able to keep an eye out for it.
Might just let the camera run now and let it get hot to see if it does it again.
Mind you, Kaushik should know how the camera behaves in the heat better than most, being in India and all…
Wayne
Wayne Avanson April 27th, 2008, 03:49 PM Ran the camera for two and a half hours straight this evening. The white dot wasn't there on the first file but was on the last. So it looks like its a heat thing.
Not good.
Wayne
David Benjamin May 3rd, 2008, 11:31 PM The dot showed up in the filming I did today too. Not in the first few clips, but in the later ones, when the camera had time to warm up. It sure seems like that's the case, although it's not like the camera's getting TOO hot. My warranty lasts a year so I'm not in a big hurry to take this anywhere just yet (especially if it means I'll be going a while without a camera). I'd like to know what people's experiences are, though, if they DO go to JVC about this.
I'm curious how widespread a problem this is. If there's a good chance that any replacement camera I get has the same problem, then I don't know that I want to deal with the hassle.
Wayne Avanson May 4th, 2008, 04:26 AM Well I have a shoot on Tuesday, then on wednesday it goes back to the shop to be sent to JVC with examples of the white dot on DVD for them to look at.
When assembling the collection of short clips for the DVD, I noticed on one of them that, as the clip faded in from black, the dot wasn't there for the first second or so, then popped into shot loud and proud. Which I thought was odd.
Hadn't noticed that before.
I am assured it will be a ten day turnaround at JVC (Yeah, right!) I'll keep you posted
Wayne
Wayne Avanson May 7th, 2008, 08:18 AM Camera went in to the shop today. I showed the guys there the problem and have sent a DVD of examples with the camera to JVC for them to see too.
Might be a few weeks before I get it back, but as soon as I know anything, I'll post it.
Incidentally, I shot some stuff on friday for a few hours and same yesterday (just shortish clips) and not a white dot anywhere to be seen. hmm…
I wonder, if anyone has the time and inclination, if they would stick their HD7 on record for a few hours and see if they have any white dots at the end of proceedings? Any help/feedback would be appreciated.
Cheers
Wayne
Sander Spies May 9th, 2008, 05:40 PM Glad I found this forum and this post! I just got the GZ HD7 camera a week ago and noticed the white dot in some of my test shots. The heat thing could be it, because the dot only showed up after while (it wasn't there in the first few shots I made).
Here's a screenshot (http://damnfinecoffee.eu/misc/JVC_GZ-HD7_white_dot.jpg) I took with VLC. Is the dot at the same location as with your cameras?
Kaushik Parmar May 9th, 2008, 08:40 PM Glad I found this forum and this post! I just got the GZ HD7 camera a week ago and noticed the white dot in some of my test shots. The heat thing could be it, because the dot only showed up after while (it wasn't there in the first few shots I made).
Here's a screenshot (http://damnfinecoffee.eu/misc/JVC_GZ-HD7_white_dot.jpg) I took with VLC. Is the dot at the same location as with your cameras?
Same happened with video also? I am afraid I am using it since last more than one year but never noticed!
Kaushik
Wayne Avanson May 10th, 2008, 01:52 AM Mine is a little more to the right, but about the same distance from the top.
I'll post an example later when I figure out how to do it.
Wayne Avanson May 11th, 2008, 08:34 AM Kaushik,
Are you saying you have the same problem?
David Benjamin May 11th, 2008, 06:18 PM Here's an example of where mine shows up. It's not nearly as bright, but it's rather persistent once it appears.
Wayne Avanson May 12th, 2008, 01:22 AM Cheers for that David. Looks like you caught a burglar trying to make a getaway in that shot.
The example of my white dot is, I admit, the worst its ever been. Sometimes it's only about as bright as yours. BUT, if there was a chance it would reappear as bright as that, then obviously I had to do something about it.
The weird thing was, that in assembling a range of clips to put on DVD to send to JVC with the camera, I noticed that when this particular clip faded in from black, it was only a second or so afterwards when the white dot 'pinged' into view. Very odd.
The chap in the shop said, "oh it'll be a dead pixel" but if there's 3 CCDs, then it would have to be the same on all three surely? and then it would also be evident ALL the time, not just when the camera got hot.
That's my bogus theory anyway. We'll wait and see what JVC say about it, if anything.
Wayne Avanson May 23rd, 2008, 08:02 AM Got the HD7 back again this afternoon, after two weeks away for repair under guarantee. The note to JVC from the shop said; 1 dead pixel on playback Approx 1/3 from top, 40% from right hand side.'
Note from JVC engineer that came back with the camera says: 'Installed software upgrade - Serviced and aligned as required.' (aligned what exactly?)
Not very helpful at all I feel, but the camera is on test as we speak and I'll see if the white dot reappears after a few hours constant filming and the camera gets good and warm.
Interesting to note that the 'software upgrade' did not alter any of my menu settings as they exactly as they were when the camera went in to the shop two weeks ago. I would have thought it would have reset everything to factory default. makes me suspicious.
Wayne Avanson May 23rd, 2008, 02:17 PM That's interesting…
it's been recording for hours and it doesn't get half as warm as it did before…
Odd.
Wayne Avanson May 23rd, 2008, 03:51 PM Well after completely filling the hard drive with 1440CBR with the camera left to run so it got warm, after reviewing the shots there's no white dot at all.
Looks promising…
Sander Spies May 23rd, 2008, 06:15 PM Hello Wayne,
Thanks for keeping us up to speed! This sounds very promising, I might go by the store this week and drop off my camera too.
Wayne Avanson May 24th, 2008, 01:44 AM yes, indeed, no white dot.
I'll do some more testing today.
David Benjamin May 24th, 2008, 12:17 PM Fantastic! Thanks for the update. I'll look into getting mine fixed/replaced.
Wayne Avanson May 25th, 2008, 02:03 AM Well I did two more lots of testing yesterday, just filling the hard drive and ten copying it to the Mac and reviewing and so far despite the camera getting quite warm, there's now evidence of the white dot.
Let's hope that's the last I've seen of it.
good luck with getting yours sorted too guys.
Wayne
Kaushik Parmar May 25th, 2008, 09:04 PM Well I did two more lots of testing yesterday, just filling the hard drive and ten copying it to the Mac and reviewing and so far despite the camera getting quite warm, there's now evidence of the white dot.
Let's hope that's the last I've seen of it.
good luck with getting yours sorted too guys.
Wayne
Wayne,
No I have not seen any dot on my video, I am glad your HD7 is not showing anymore that white dot! Have you posted your videos online? So then I can see your work!
Kaushik
Wayne Avanson May 27th, 2008, 03:32 PM Hi Kaushik,
I don't have any videos posted yet as most of my stuff has been for clients and it's not fair that I use their material on the web without permission.
I have some holiday footage (megabytage?) in SP which I shot in the States last October which I might post sometime.
Have done some more testing today and still no white dot so I'm actually starting to believe it may actually be properly fixed.
Good stuff.
Wayne Avanson May 29th, 2008, 01:16 AM Hi Guys,
have put a couple of experimental pieces up on Vimeo
http://www.vimeo.com/user506080/videos
These were both done with the HD7
Wayne Avanson June 16th, 2008, 12:16 PM David and Sander,
any news on your HD7s? Have they been sorted yet.
Mine still has no white dot so I'm very pleased with the outcome, just wondered about yours
Sander Spies June 16th, 2008, 06:10 PM Hello Wayne!
The camera was needed last week and I need it myself this friday. Returning it for repair was not an option since I have no other HD camera to work with. Probably bring to to the store this friday after filming is done. I'll keep you posted! It's good to hear your white dot has gone!
David Benjamin June 16th, 2008, 11:26 PM Since I'm past the first period of my warranty (free parts or free labor... I forget which), and I'm pretty much filming every week or every two weeks, I'm going to wait for a while before getting this fixed. In the meantime, I'm using a friend's HD7 as my "A" camera and have relegated the "white dot" HD7 as the "B" camera, taking care to turn it off whenever possible to limit the prevalence of the dot. With this method, I should only see the dot on maybe 5% of my remaining footage, and I can fix that in Final Cut Pro, so it's not a huge concern. Just an annoyance.
My friend had purchased his HD7 at a Best Buy and had paid for their warranty, and we were GOING to see if we could take advantage of that benefit... except no Best Buy remotely near us has one in stock. All they have is the HD6, which I have zero interest in due to the lack of manual controls/focus ring, and the horrible front placement of the accessory shoe. (I have a mic that would stick so far out on that camera, it would be in the top of every shot!)
Once we have a decent break time in our filming (or maybe once we're done), we'll go the repair route.
Wayne Avanson June 17th, 2008, 07:04 AM OK Guys I appreciate the situations, I was in that position myself and had to wait for a break before taking it back.
I'd love to pick up another one for the odd occasion I have need of two but since things are happening on the JVC front at the moment, I'm not sure whether to wait and see if they come up with a true replacement for the HD7 with some proper progressive capture. Since I'm not in a rush, the latter option is more likely.
Keep me up to speed when you get sorted, for, well no apparent reason really, just interested,
all the best
Avey
Sander Spies June 26th, 2008, 06:27 PM The strangest thing happened. I'm preparing some demo material to show when returning the camera to point out the problem. But all of a sudden the white dot has changed location! It's now located in the bottom right half of the screen instead of center middle...
Edit: Hm, ok the other dot is back, so I've got 2 dots, they show up depending on the amount of light... I'll try to make a screenshot with both pixels visible.
Wayne Avanson June 27th, 2008, 12:43 AM How odd. Mind you, mine was always intermittent. More on than off towards the end but still, not always there. Thing with that is, you can guarantee that when it's the most important, that's when it would appear.
Sander Spies July 7th, 2008, 07:09 AM Well, the cam is back to JVC. It'll be back in 2 to 3 weeks. Let's hope the software update/adjustment works!
My (3!) dots on video: http://vimeo.com/1260185
Wayne Avanson July 7th, 2008, 07:30 AM Nice One Sander, and take heart, mine is STILL white dot free and working like a little gem
Check out some of my little experiments. And there's quite a few nice people on Vimeo using the same camera.
http://www.vimeo.com/user506080/videos
Your dots behave like my dot did, sometimes larger sometimes smaller depending on the background it's laid against. In fact, I couldn't see the one on the left until right near the end of your clip.
So, let me know when you're dot-free.
Gary Colon July 13th, 2008, 12:26 AM Yo, this sucks man!! I got a dot, just one and I noticed it a few months back. I thought it was my LCD screen, then noticed video in other peeps screens had it too, so then I even noticed it on my JVC LCD screen!! Anyways, Ive had mine, pretty much since these babies started selling 2 yrs (??) ago. Anyways, I JUST registered mine tonight, is there anyway into tricking the JVC site and buying an extended 5 yr warranty?? Would they require receipt or anything or just the fact that I registered it last night?? If they required receipt (I could get a reprint from Circuit City)...any possible way of photoshopping and changing the date or something?? Anyways, hope everyone elses gets fixed!! Thanks!!
GC
Wayne Avanson July 13th, 2008, 02:52 AM That's bad news dude. Best speak to Circuit City first, they would probably be more sympathetic to printing you a receipt with a new date on. I know that the shop I bought mine from printed out the receipt for me to send off with the camera because I forgot to bring my original one to the shop with me.
This doesn't seem like a widespread problem as there's only four people I know who have experienced it, but it's still something I'm sure that JVC are well aware of.
Gary Colon July 13th, 2008, 09:48 AM That's bad news dude. Best speak to Circuit City first, they would probably be more sympathetic to printing you a receipt with a new date on. I know that the shop I bought mine from printed out the receipt for me to send off with the camera because I forgot to bring my original one to the shop with me.
This doesn't seem like a widespread problem as there's only four people I know who have experienced it, but it's still something I'm sure that JVC are well aware of.
Yea, it just kinda sucks you know. I got this thing when it FIRST came out which was like $1499. I think Im gonna have to get on the inside with someone and see if they cant print me out a new receipt with a new purchase date. Im gonna see if there is no way I can photoshop you know? Somehow lay the receipt on printer paper and reprint. Those Circuit City receipts are CRAPPY, they fade out completely after a few months. I could probably get a faded one out, copy everything onto it lol.
Wayne Avanson July 13th, 2008, 09:57 AM Or do your photoshopping and then print it out to look like you just photocopied the real receipt… send photocopies of the warranty and stuff to back it up, like you 'don't trust the post with the real stuff'. HA!
Send them a DVD of clips showing the white dot too, that's what I did and it helped.
Gary Colon July 13th, 2008, 10:44 AM Or do your photoshopping and then print it out to look like you just photocopied the real receipt… send photocopies of the warranty and stuff to back it up, like you 'don't trust the post with the real stuff'. HA!
Send them a DVD of clips showing the white dot too, that's what I did and it helped.
lol, yea. I gotta figure something out, I dont know. Hopefully I can somehow trick them into fixing my camera for free. Ill keep updating this as things go! Thanks
Sander Spies July 16th, 2008, 01:26 PM Be careful though with faking a receipt, it may get you on some sort of blacklist by JVC (technically it's fraud). They can probably also figure out from the camera's firmware/internal memory/whatever when the first recording was made.
Since this is a somewhat known problem, not caused by using the device in a wrong way, they might repair it for free, or at a low cost. All they do is update/recalibrate the sofware (at least that's what I am told).
Ps: mine is back from JVC, I can pick it up tomorrow at the store!
Wayne Avanson July 16th, 2008, 02:01 PM good point Sander. I guess being more up front about it would be better.
Let us know how yours is tomorrow. looking forward to another satisfied customer!
Sander Spies July 18th, 2008, 08:25 PM A quick update: it looks like the dots are gone! I'm going to test some more tomorrow.
Richard Boyer July 20th, 2008, 03:16 PM Sander...
Did you send yours off, or did the dot just go away. I've started noticing it on my camera, sometimes it's there for a full shot, sometimes it's not at all.
Hard to figure out what it is... it definetly appears when I'm wearing a white t-shirt and close to the camera... if I step farther back it goes away instantly. I thought it was a focus issue, but after messing with that, the focus itself didn't appear to cause the issue. I think certain colors are triggering the dot on mine...
Regardless, I'm probably going to send mine off soon, because it's annoying me, alot!
Wayne Avanson July 20th, 2008, 04:27 PM A quick update: it looks like the dots are gone! I'm going to test some more tomorrow.
Good news Sander, looking hopeful. Keep us posted!
Wayne Avanson July 20th, 2008, 04:31 PM Richard,
Most of the people here have experienced a white dot, how come you're only seeing it when it's against a white Tshirt? or is that just when it's the most noticeable?
I personally noticed it most against darker colours, especially against black. But the dot was intermittent. Sometimes on a shoot and sometimes not. I couldn't have that, not when I had to stuff for clients.
If you have any problem with the camera at all with white dots, then I definitely recommend getting JVC to sort it for you. Two weeks without, is well worth it to get it fixed. I'm certainly glad I did.
Gary Colon July 21st, 2008, 07:53 PM Good news Sander, looking hopeful. Keep us posted!
I really love this camera, but this dot thing is killing me, though I have yet to see it in a few weeks, even when recording for long periods of time. I would really like to get 2 more, especially now since they are like $7-$800. What do you think??
GC
Richard Boyer July 28th, 2008, 06:16 PM Wayne... Sorry I didn't reply right away, I was out of town. I can make mine come and go by changing the color in the shot and focus of the camera. It isn't just white I noticed... a good example (I'll upload a clip when I get time)... is that if I have it in auto focus mode... I can put my hand 6 inches in front of the lens, and the dot goes away, but as I move my hand back, the dot pops up again.
It's very wierd... but regardless, I will take your advice and send it off for repair.
Thanks,
Richard
Wayne Avanson August 6th, 2008, 01:14 AM I really love this camera, but this dot thing is killing me, though I have yet to see it in a few weeks, even when recording for long periods of time. I would really like to get 2 more, especially now since they are like $7-$800. What do you think??
GC
I'm considering getting another myself. The white dot thing is a very isolated problem and has affected only a few of us. Since you can get it fixed easily enough through the warranty, I wouldn't worry about it. Get em while they're cheap! I don't think JVC has come up with anything as good to replace it, and I understand they're switching to AVHCD soon.
Avey
|
|