Chris Soucy
March 27th, 2008, 06:09 PM
This is a follow up to this thread:
http://dvinfo.net/conf/showthread.php?t=109813
which came to a grinding halt as someone else got the job.
However, I went along as an ordinary Joe Public anyway, and came away with a large number of valuable lessons and a decent dose of sunburn to boot.
As mentioned in the original thread, the event was spread over three days, Friday the 21st March being the first day open to the public tho' the air displays were only "practice" for the following two days.
Being just me, myself and I, one look at the huge pile of gear I was thinking of taking along brought lesson number 1 : One person attempting both video and stills with the respective hardware requirements of both simply doesn't work.
So, I kyboshed video on Friday and concentrated on stills. I'm glad I did as the place was a gigantic dust bowl due to lack of rain and every whiff of jet/ propellor wash raised a dust storm of Saharen proportions. My Nikon D80 will never be the same again!
The UV levels in Wanaka really caused some problems, the first being it's ability to penetrate both SPF 30+ sunblock AND clothing with impunity, the second due to the sunblock working as an extremely efficient dust gatherer, thus ensuring that by days end I looked more like a chimney sweep than a photog (with a decent dose of sunburn to boot).
Luckily that night it did rain, hard, which meant that at least on Saturday the dust problem was solved. I thought the 10/10 cloud cover had solved the UV problem too but was proved wrong, as I got nailed again.
I had to make some hard choices as to video gear, as the treck from car to viewing area was legthy and more than one journey was out of the question. I settled for the Canon XH A1, my beutifull FiberTec's and a rucksack with external mic's, cables, mic stand, spare tapes and batteries for everything and a host of other bits and pieces (cleaning stuff etc). With everything on board I felt more like a pack mule than anything else.
Luckily the Saturday was considerably cooler than the Friday, but I had still worked up quite a sweat by the time I made the viewing area. I had hoped to be able to get a spot right on the fence line, but about 10,000 others had had the same idea and beaten me to it, so I had no choice but to set up about 20 feet back in what was at the time a relatively empty part of the viewing area. Within moments of the first aircraft appearing the entire viewing area was standing room only and I was surrounded.
At this stage it was apparent that about 40 percent of the displays were going to be either partially or completely blocked by heads & hats, as the camera lens with the tripod @ max was only about 66 inches off the ground. Lesson learnt: if you can't get above the crowd you're toast. Sure enough, I have at least an hour of perfectly shot HD of the back of heads and hats!
However, the tripod hadn't finished with me just yet. Many of the fly past's encompassed an arc of at least 240 degrees, which meant that those tripod legs had to be either avoided or collected, within an hour my shins were black and blue from colliding with those very solid carbon fibre girders. The choice here was stark - look down and miss the leg (and the target) or prance around the tripod like some deranged ballerina and hope I'd miss the leg or at least if I collected it not fall flat on my face (I have an excellent clip of me doing a header directly across the shot, having collected a leg, tried to regain my balance, pushed the pan bar away, let go of the pan bar etc etc - gracefull, NOT!).
Still the tripod hadn't finished! A number of the more spectacular aerobatics involved the aircraft coming out of a steep dive directly on the flight line (only some 10 metres away) and going into a vertical climb almost directly over the camera position. Yep, you've guessed, no matter what I tried, the pan bar would collect a leg as I tilted up and come to a sudden stop mid climb. Raising the pan bar to allow total vertical tilt even with a leg in the way made the Lanc remote unusable and the bar impossible to use for anything close to level. Lesson learnt: Live shows really need a pedestal support of some sort.
The audio problems with the three hours of footage I shot came as a bit of a suprise but should really have been expected. I had a Senn ME67 on the camera and a ME66 on a stand about 5 feet away pointed vaguely up at one of the PA speakers. As no amount of fidling with levels could keep track of the huge discrepancies in sound volume, I had to set the audio to Auto, which, of course, meant that every time a plane got REAL close I completely lost the PA and most of the ambience as the pre amps shut down. Sounds awefull on playback.
My focus problems I had been expecting, and were, as expected, severe. One lone head/ hat in bottom centre shot was enough to give the autofocus system a nervous breakdown, losing the target completely or wildly racking in and out from one to the other - looks dire on the screen. Manual focus was simply not an option. When I did get a clear shot the system did work pretty well as long as I kept the framing tight, but that caused it's own problems.
Trying to close frame an F111 fighter traversing the flight line from 3 miles out to only 30 metres away then back out to three miles whilst it's doing 1000 kph is an art form I haven't quite got off pat, and I really wish the A1 had some way to limit the zoom range to a max setting, say Z80. Just about anything past that showed so much pan/ tilt judder as to make the shots unusable (this judder shows up due to my inability to kep the target perfectly centered in the frame at such high pan speeds whilst trying to gently squeeze the zoom rocker to keep the zoom smooth and the target relatively close to full frame).
About the only thing that was a (relatively) resounding success was the exposure. I set it manually with about 1/3 back/ heads/ hats and 2/3rd sky, meant the clouds/ sky were about 5 stops overexposed on a pure sky shot but the planes were nigh on perfect. Nice to get something right!
Will I do it again? Maybe, if I can resolve most of the problems shown up this time around. Out of the three hours shot I reckon I've got about 10 minutes or reasonable video, which is not a lot for such hard work. If I can't resolve them I might just go along for the show and buy the DVD!
CS
http://dvinfo.net/conf/showthread.php?t=109813
which came to a grinding halt as someone else got the job.
However, I went along as an ordinary Joe Public anyway, and came away with a large number of valuable lessons and a decent dose of sunburn to boot.
As mentioned in the original thread, the event was spread over three days, Friday the 21st March being the first day open to the public tho' the air displays were only "practice" for the following two days.
Being just me, myself and I, one look at the huge pile of gear I was thinking of taking along brought lesson number 1 : One person attempting both video and stills with the respective hardware requirements of both simply doesn't work.
So, I kyboshed video on Friday and concentrated on stills. I'm glad I did as the place was a gigantic dust bowl due to lack of rain and every whiff of jet/ propellor wash raised a dust storm of Saharen proportions. My Nikon D80 will never be the same again!
The UV levels in Wanaka really caused some problems, the first being it's ability to penetrate both SPF 30+ sunblock AND clothing with impunity, the second due to the sunblock working as an extremely efficient dust gatherer, thus ensuring that by days end I looked more like a chimney sweep than a photog (with a decent dose of sunburn to boot).
Luckily that night it did rain, hard, which meant that at least on Saturday the dust problem was solved. I thought the 10/10 cloud cover had solved the UV problem too but was proved wrong, as I got nailed again.
I had to make some hard choices as to video gear, as the treck from car to viewing area was legthy and more than one journey was out of the question. I settled for the Canon XH A1, my beutifull FiberTec's and a rucksack with external mic's, cables, mic stand, spare tapes and batteries for everything and a host of other bits and pieces (cleaning stuff etc). With everything on board I felt more like a pack mule than anything else.
Luckily the Saturday was considerably cooler than the Friday, but I had still worked up quite a sweat by the time I made the viewing area. I had hoped to be able to get a spot right on the fence line, but about 10,000 others had had the same idea and beaten me to it, so I had no choice but to set up about 20 feet back in what was at the time a relatively empty part of the viewing area. Within moments of the first aircraft appearing the entire viewing area was standing room only and I was surrounded.
At this stage it was apparent that about 40 percent of the displays were going to be either partially or completely blocked by heads & hats, as the camera lens with the tripod @ max was only about 66 inches off the ground. Lesson learnt: if you can't get above the crowd you're toast. Sure enough, I have at least an hour of perfectly shot HD of the back of heads and hats!
However, the tripod hadn't finished with me just yet. Many of the fly past's encompassed an arc of at least 240 degrees, which meant that those tripod legs had to be either avoided or collected, within an hour my shins were black and blue from colliding with those very solid carbon fibre girders. The choice here was stark - look down and miss the leg (and the target) or prance around the tripod like some deranged ballerina and hope I'd miss the leg or at least if I collected it not fall flat on my face (I have an excellent clip of me doing a header directly across the shot, having collected a leg, tried to regain my balance, pushed the pan bar away, let go of the pan bar etc etc - gracefull, NOT!).
Still the tripod hadn't finished! A number of the more spectacular aerobatics involved the aircraft coming out of a steep dive directly on the flight line (only some 10 metres away) and going into a vertical climb almost directly over the camera position. Yep, you've guessed, no matter what I tried, the pan bar would collect a leg as I tilted up and come to a sudden stop mid climb. Raising the pan bar to allow total vertical tilt even with a leg in the way made the Lanc remote unusable and the bar impossible to use for anything close to level. Lesson learnt: Live shows really need a pedestal support of some sort.
The audio problems with the three hours of footage I shot came as a bit of a suprise but should really have been expected. I had a Senn ME67 on the camera and a ME66 on a stand about 5 feet away pointed vaguely up at one of the PA speakers. As no amount of fidling with levels could keep track of the huge discrepancies in sound volume, I had to set the audio to Auto, which, of course, meant that every time a plane got REAL close I completely lost the PA and most of the ambience as the pre amps shut down. Sounds awefull on playback.
My focus problems I had been expecting, and were, as expected, severe. One lone head/ hat in bottom centre shot was enough to give the autofocus system a nervous breakdown, losing the target completely or wildly racking in and out from one to the other - looks dire on the screen. Manual focus was simply not an option. When I did get a clear shot the system did work pretty well as long as I kept the framing tight, but that caused it's own problems.
Trying to close frame an F111 fighter traversing the flight line from 3 miles out to only 30 metres away then back out to three miles whilst it's doing 1000 kph is an art form I haven't quite got off pat, and I really wish the A1 had some way to limit the zoom range to a max setting, say Z80. Just about anything past that showed so much pan/ tilt judder as to make the shots unusable (this judder shows up due to my inability to kep the target perfectly centered in the frame at such high pan speeds whilst trying to gently squeeze the zoom rocker to keep the zoom smooth and the target relatively close to full frame).
About the only thing that was a (relatively) resounding success was the exposure. I set it manually with about 1/3 back/ heads/ hats and 2/3rd sky, meant the clouds/ sky were about 5 stops overexposed on a pure sky shot but the planes were nigh on perfect. Nice to get something right!
Will I do it again? Maybe, if I can resolve most of the problems shown up this time around. Out of the three hours shot I reckon I've got about 10 minutes or reasonable video, which is not a lot for such hard work. If I can't resolve them I might just go along for the show and buy the DVD!
CS